**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Mon Jun 12 03:00:03 2017
Jun 12 06:15:07 <thetransformerr> hi ds2:
Jun 12 06:15:34 <thetransformerr> did you received maxim board
Jun 12 06:15:58 <thetransformerr> and do you have some idea abt Adjustable Amplitude Threshold???
Jun 12 06:51:56 * ravikp7[m] sent a long message: ravikp7[m]_2017-06-12_06:51:55.txt <https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/v1/download/matrix.org/etzlpTCkuOpSKSoWRJwldiQu>
Jun 12 06:52:27 <ravikp7[m]> I need help in debugging it
Jun 12 15:03:26 <thetransformerr[> at last received the bbb
Jun 12 16:39:05 <ravikp7> jkridner ,  av500 , nerdboy : please help me in configuring spl for tftp transfer of uboot over usb
Jun 12 16:49:03 <ravikp7> pmezydlo: Hi, can you help here please ? I'm new to this
Jun 12 16:49:36 <pmezydlo> hi, ok what is your problem
Jun 12 16:50:44 <ravikp7> I'm build spl/uboot with config am335x_evm_usbspl_defconfig
Jun 12 16:50:50 <m_w> ravikp7: can you post the configuration file for your u-boot build?
Jun 12 16:51:33 <ravikp7> m_w: sure, wait
Jun 12 16:54:07 <m_w> ravikp7: here is a forum post that might be useful: https://e2e.ti.com/support/arm/sitara_arm/f/791/t/515767
Jun 12 16:55:23 <ravikp7> m_w: I already checked out it, the solution asks to build with am335x_evm_usbspl_defconfig which I'm doing, still no success
Jun 12 16:56:07 * ravikp7 posted a file: .config (21KB) <https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/v1/download/matrix.org/wzEvmRCvheSNxuVrhYGDRgmv>
Jun 12 16:57:43 <nerdboy> i had to patch that last time when i tried...
Jun 12 17:01:02 <ravikp7> nerdboy: please share the patch
Jun 12 17:02:28 * ravikp7 posted a file: .config (21KB) <https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/v1/download/matrix.org/bEbpXhAyTcQjEsiGQOUFKpRS>
Jun 12 17:12:59 <nerdboy> not sure what happened to it...
Jun 12 17:13:49 <nerdboy> it was just a test for building mass storage support
Jun 12 17:14:58 <ravikp7> nerdboy: test was successful?
Jun 12 17:15:22 <nerdboy> commit b3cab814232d3b5e165c09ffad4af5b71bde15f3  <= looks like somebody had to fix ums for imx6ul
Jun 12 17:16:31 <m_w> CONFIG_SPL_NET_VCI_STRING="AM335x U-Boot SPL"
Jun 12 17:16:41 <m_w> try add this to the configuration
Jun 12 17:17:24 <m_w> *adding
Jun 12 17:17:36 <ravikp7> m_w: ok..
Jun 12 17:42:47 <m_w> ravikp7: any luck?
Jun 12 17:43:05 <ravikp7> m_w: nopes, same
Jun 12 17:45:36 <m_w> what does you /etc/dhcp/dhcpd.conf file look like?
Jun 12 17:46:53 <ravikp7> m_w: I'm using the node.js usb bootloader server that I'm developing
Jun 12 17:49:58 <ravikp7> m_w: I transferred BBBlfs's pre compiled spl binary through this server, it booted well
Jun 12 17:52:10 <m_w> ravikp7: so your server handles the IP leasing to the device?
Jun 12 17:52:21 <ravikp7> m_w: yes
Jun 12 17:57:45 <m_w> looking at your code
Jun 12 17:58:00 <ravikp7> hmm
Jun 12 18:04:00 <m_w> the boot sequence will first need the spl image transfer then when the spl loads it will request the regular img
Jun 12 18:04:31 <m_w> is your code transfering the regular image after the spl?
Jun 12 18:04:43 <ravikp7> not yet
Jun 12 18:04:52 <ravikp7> just spl for now
Jun 12 18:05:03 <m_w> that is the problem
Jun 12 18:05:06 <m_w> :)
Jun 12 18:05:34 <m_w> the SPL is only used to load the img file
Jun 12 18:06:24 <m_w> you would need to provide the regular u-boot.img on the subsequent request from the spl image
Jun 12 18:07:35 <ravikp7> but when I transfer the BBBlfs's pre compiled spl binary, it boots and waits for tftp of uboot, wait I'll share its serial output
Jun 12 18:07:48 <m_w> okay
Jun 12 18:09:47 <ravikp7> m_w: https://pastebin.com/rm75xejk
Jun 12 18:10:28 <m_w> okay
Jun 12 18:11:00 <m_w> with the new bootloader is there a delay before the ### ERROR ### Please RESET the board ###
Jun 12 18:11:20 <ravikp7> no
Jun 12 18:11:26 <ds2> is the ethernet driver compiled into the SPL image
Jun 12 18:11:53 <m_w> I think he is using MUSB
Jun 12 18:12:18 <ds2> does the SPL even have the option to put in the MUSB driver?!
Jun 12 18:12:35 <ds2> didn't think there was that much memory
Jun 12 18:16:58 <ravikp7> ds2: I don't see ethernet included in the config that I'm using am335x_evm_usbspl_defconfig
Jun 12 18:20:21 <ravikp7> and yes, musb is included
Jun 12 18:22:38 <ds2> ravikp7:what kind of host are you using?
Jun 12 18:23:45 <ravikp7> ds2: usb server, currently node.js server that I'm porting from BBBlfs
Jun 12 18:26:01 <m_w> the bbblfs uses a really old bootloader and much has changed since then
Jun 12 18:26:44 <ravikp7> m_w: yes, that confuses a newbie like me a lot :(
Jun 12 18:26:52 <m_w> ravikp7: you know how to do a git bisect?
Jun 12 18:27:28 <ravikp7> m_w: not yet
Jun 12 18:27:32 <ds2> yes, what kind of host?
Jun 12 18:27:49 <ds2> Linux? Windows? OS/2? NT? BSD?
Jun 12 18:27:59 <ravikp7> Linux
Jun 12 18:28:32 <ds2> ravikp7: okay, look at the kernel messages and see what is it doing - there should probally be a re-enumeration between ROM and SPL
Jun 12 18:28:45 <ds2> see if the SPL one succeeds and if you get a usb device
Jun 12 18:29:38 <ravikp7> yes, the BBBlfs's spl succeeds and I get the spl usb device
Jun 12 18:30:17 <m_w> SPL_USBETH_SUPPORT
Jun 12 18:30:45 <ds2> does DHCP succeed for the SPL part?
Jun 12 18:33:08 <ravikp7> ds2: bb is leased ip from server, and tftp request is made by the bb to the server, so spl part is done
Jun 12 18:34:48 <m_w> ravikp7: CONFIG_SYS_EXTRA_OPTIONS="NAND,SPL_USBETH_SUPPORT"
Jun 12 18:35:16 <m_w> it looks like it only has CONFIG_SYS_EXTRA_OPTIONS="NAND" in the config you sent
Jun 12 18:35:38 <ravikp7> m_w: ok, trying this
Jun 12 18:36:59 <ds2> ravikp7: so you see SPL's TFTP request?
Jun 12 18:37:18 <ravikp7> ds2: yes
Jun 12 18:39:01 <ravikp7> SPL tftp request ( udp packet)
Jun 12 18:39:02 <ravikp7> { udpSrc: 1234, udpDest: 69, udpLen: 20, chkSum: 32823 }
Jun 12 18:39:19 <m_w> with the new bootloader?
Jun 12 18:39:20 <ds2> what is the requested path?
Jun 12 18:39:34 <ds2> tftp servers can be picky
Jun 12 18:39:50 <ds2> some want /tftpboot/foo, others want just /foo, yet others want "foo"
Jun 12 18:42:56 <ravikp7> I think it doesn't use any path, just the udp ports
Jun 12 18:43:28 <m_w> the server that you use dicates the path
Jun 12 18:43:51 <m_w> since you are providing the server, it is up to you
Jun 12 18:44:04 <ds2> got to run
Jun 12 18:44:20 <m_w> ravikp7: did the SPL_USBETH_SUPPORT thing help?
Jun 12 18:44:57 <ravikp7> m_w: no, getting error on build
Jun 12 18:44:58 * ravikp7 sent a long message: ravikp7_2017-06-12_18:44:58.txt <https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/v1/download/matrix.org/ELUTDjwEiKRiGooyIWkPfYWf>
Jun 12 18:45:22 <m_w> you need to config in the usb code :)
Jun 12 18:45:34 <m_w> CONFIG_USB=y
Jun 12 18:45:59 <ravikp7> ok, got it :)
Jun 12 18:46:20 <m_w> lemme pull the latest source so we can figure this out
Jun 12 18:46:53 <ravikp7> m_w: yeah, that would be good, thanks!
Jun 12 18:48:20 <m_w> you need the gadget ethernet driver
Jun 12 18:48:56 <m_w> CONFIG_USB_ETHER
Jun 12 18:49:06 <m_w> CONFIG_USB_ETH_RNDIS
Jun 12 18:50:49 <m_w> CONFIG_SPL_USB_GADGET_SUPPORT
Jun 12 18:55:25 <m_w> make sure these are set in the configuration
Jun 12 18:56:12 <ravikp7> ok..
Jun 12 19:07:59 <m_w> ravikp7: so it says that we run out of space with the drivers added in
Jun 12 19:08:12 <m_w> so I dropped a few configs to make space
Jun 12 19:08:37 <m_w> I have a binary now, how do I test it with your code?
Jun 12 19:09:10 <ravikp7> just put as ./bin/spl
Jun 12 19:09:15 <ravikp7> npm install
Jun 12 19:09:22 <ravikp7> sudo npm start
Jun 12 19:09:34 <m_w> lemme clone the repo
Jun 12 19:09:46 <ravikp7> or share binary with me :)
Jun 12 19:11:22 <ravikp7> yeah, I'm too getting out of space error
Jun 12 19:11:37 <m_w> what do you have to do with the beagle?
Jun 12 19:12:03 <ravikp7> press boot switch and connect usb
Jun 12 19:12:21 <m_w> okay
Jun 12 19:13:53 <m_w> getting an error with npm install
Jun 12 19:14:13 <ravikp7> try with sudo
Jun 12 19:15:33 <m_w> npm ERR! Failed at the deasync@0.1.9 install script.
Jun 12 19:16:09 <ravikp7> what node ver are you using?
Jun 12 19:16:45 <m_w> v0.10.29
Jun 12 19:16:56 <m_w> it is what debiain installed
Jun 12 19:17:21 <m_w> lemme try some things
Jun 12 19:17:32 <ravikp7> that's much older, I expect it not to run there
Jun 12 19:18:11 <ravikp7> Try BBBlfs ?
Jun 12 19:19:24 <ravikp7> btw I'm using node 7.x
Jun 12 19:20:26 <m_w> installing 8.x
Jun 12 19:20:33 <m_w> one sec
Jun 12 19:20:42 <m_w> not a node guy usually
Jun 12 19:27:48 <m_w> now it is complaining about /etc/package.json not existing
Jun 12 19:32:37 <ravikp7> m_w: while installing node?
Jun 12 19:35:34 <m_w> I was doing the commands in the wrong directory :)
Jun 12 19:40:34 * nerdboy needs to vacuum out the dust dinosaurs today...
Jun 12 19:46:06 <m_w> ravikp7: guessing I need the serial cable to see the u-boot output :)
Jun 12 19:46:22 <ravikp7> m_w: yes :)
Jun 12 19:46:41 <m_w> lemme just send you the binary and config
Jun 12 19:46:53 <ravikp7> ok..
Jun 12 19:48:02 <m_w> let me know if it works
Jun 12 19:48:13 <m_w> I am gonna dig out my serial cable
Jun 12 19:50:32 <ravikp7> hmm
Jun 12 19:52:04 <m_w> ravikp7: did it boot?
Jun 12 19:52:23 <ravikp7> m_w: yes, it's working
Jun 12 19:53:52 <ravikp7> m_w: https://pastebin.com/MbKfB7bF
Jun 12 19:54:17 <m_w> go to go
Jun 12 19:54:24 <m_w> first try
Jun 12 19:56:32 <m_w> now just add support for the secondary load
Jun 12 19:58:35 <ravikp7> m_w: what config file you used first? and added what config options to it?
Jun 12 19:58:58 <m_w> I started from the default
Jun 12 19:59:30 <m_w> make am335x_evm_usbspl_defconfig
Jun 12 19:59:36 <m_w> make menuconfig
Jun 12 20:00:19 <m_w> (clicked the menu a bit to get the config I sent)
Jun 12 20:00:26 <m_w> make -j8
Jun 12 20:01:36 <m_w> this is why they pay me the big bucks ;)
Jun 12 20:02:05 <ravikp7> m_w: yeah, :)
Jun 12 20:02:16 <ravikp7> m_w: Thanks
Jun 12 20:02:47 <ravikp7> m_w: you added usb gadget, ethernet ?
Jun 12 20:03:06 <ravikp7> anything else included ?
Jun 12 20:03:22 <ravikp7> and removed what ?
Jun 12 20:04:49 <m_w> lemme show you the configuration diff
Jun 12 20:05:35 <m_w> https://pastebin.com/BD1VKQJ1
Jun 12 20:06:19 <m_w> took out the NAND support, MTD support and YMODEM support
Jun 12 20:06:45 <m_w> added SPL gadget and SPL USB ethernet
Jun 12 20:07:25 <ravikp7> m_w: great! thank you so much :)
Jun 12 20:07:46 <m_w> no problem
Jun 12 20:08:31 <m_w> I would create a new defconfig for the beaglebone black and push it upstream
Jun 12 20:08:58 <ravikp7> m_w: awesome!
**** ENDING LOGGING AT Tue Jun 13 03:00:00 2017