**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Thu Feb 15 03:00:02 2018
Feb 15 06:50:07 <Tofe> Herrie: https://paste2.org/gvVgm8h8
Feb 15 07:35:10 <Herrie> Morning!
Feb 15 07:35:14 <Herrie> Tofe: What's that?
Feb 15 08:04:08 <Herrie|Pre3> Tofe: I guess it woud be helpful to have output of all *test* binaries so I know which outputs are normal
Feb 15 08:07:12 <Herrie|Pre3> I.e. I see some errors in mine but not sure those are normal"
Feb 15 08:36:47 <Tofe> Herrie: That's Hammerhead's LuneOS "ps axf"
Feb 15 08:37:15 <Tofe> ... and I realize that's not what you asked for. Never do anything before the first coffee !
Feb 15 08:38:20 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: LOL
Feb 15 08:38:33 <Herrie|Laptop> Just I'd like to understand if some of the "errors" or failures I am getting are normal or not
Feb 15 08:40:23 <Herrie|Laptop> I.e. some of the sensor*_test give me "funny" outputs
Feb 15 08:50:01 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: Had a long night of sleep, could sleep till 6 today, luxury LOL :P
Feb 15 09:06:01 <Tofe> :)
Feb 15 09:53:03 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: On https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/tree/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system/android-system I guess we can remove init.rc completely?
Feb 15 09:53:33 <Herrie|Laptop> https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system/android-system/lxc-config#L26 should be updated to remove the hal-droid ones and add the lib64 ones?
Feb 15 09:56:49 <Herrie|Laptop> On https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system/android-system/20-remove-services I think we can delete lines 4, 10, 11 and maybe 12, 13?
Feb 15 09:57:15 <Herrie|Laptop> Not really sure what the mediaserver does on Android side?
Feb 15 09:58:56 <Herrie|Laptop> Not sure about the sensorservice and surfaceflinger either... You know those better I guess
Feb 15 10:06:59 <Tofe> Herrie|Laptop: things that are not even pointed by the recipe can be removed, yes, it'll be a little cleanup
Feb 15 10:08:08 <Tofe> And the lxc.environment can be removed too completely yes
Feb 15 10:08:20 <Tofe> (it's even possible it gets in the way instead of helping)
Feb 15 10:09:27 <Tofe> For the ubuntu stuff removal, we'll just have to confirm it's actually not there anymore with Halium
Feb 15 10:19:59 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: If I look in the image, I don't have ubuntuappmanager, upstart-property-watcher and surfaceflinger
Feb 15 10:20:31 <Herrie|Laptop> And no ubuntu_chroot
Feb 15 10:20:49 <Herrie|Laptop> So those should be able to go for sure
Feb 15 10:24:07 <Herrie|Laptop> Question now is if we need sensorservice & mediaserver
Feb 15 10:30:49 <Tofe> Herrie: at this point, let's just try to use directly Halium's init.rc
Feb 15 10:31:01 <Tofe> so ignore completely 20-remove
Feb 15 10:31:29 <Tofe> We'll have to validate it for N4,N5 and TP of course
Feb 15 10:36:07 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe:
Feb 15 10:36:09 <Herrie|Laptop>  OK
Feb 15 10:36:18 <Herrie|Laptop> Let me try that for Mido first see what it does
Feb 15 10:40:02 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: For udev rules, sometimes I see ACTION=="add" and sometimes without
Feb 15 10:40:06 <Herrie|Laptop> You know what's the difference?
Feb 15 10:41:01 <Herrie|Laptop> I.e. the one I generated with the command has the ACTION=="add"' in there, but the ones from Piggz doesn't have: https://github.com/piggz/droid-config-mido/blob/master/sparse/lib/udev/rules.d/999-droid-fm.rules and https://github.com/piggz/droid-config-mido/blob/master/sparse/lib/udev/rules.d/999-droid-vidc.rules
Feb 15 10:52:47 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: Seems our lxc-config is very similar to Halium's: https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system/android-system/lxc-config#L26 and https://github.com/Halium/lxc-android/blob/9ca601468de119b1245756fe49b640202ac8ca77/var/lib/lxc/android/config
Feb 15 10:54:04 <Herrie|Laptop> Only differences are that we have lxc.environment, lxc.hook.post-stop which Halium doesn't. Halium has lxc.init_cmd = /init  lxc.aa_profile = unconfined and lxc.autodev = 0 which we don't have
Feb 15 11:37:11 <Herrie|Laptop> JaMa: Hi :)
Feb 15 11:42:52 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: I don't seem to have adverse things on Mido when removing the 20-remove and removing the lxc.environment
Feb 15 12:17:11 <JaMa> Herrie|Laptop: hi
Feb 15 12:21:16 <Herrie|Pre3> JaMa: I'll PR some meta-smartphone stuff later :)
Feb 15 12:21:33 <Herrie|Pre3> Almost got LuneOS to run on my Mido finally :)
Feb 15 12:21:45 <bshah> oh
Feb 15 12:21:52 <bshah> "almost"?
Feb 15 12:21:53 <Herrie|Pre3> Just gstreamer is now segfaulting preventing UI from coming up....
Feb 15 12:22:18 <JaMa> Herrie|Pre3: ok :)
Feb 15 12:23:27 <Herrie|Pre3> bshah: well test_hwcomposer works, just ui fails on libgstreamer stuff
Feb 15 12:24:59 <Tofe> Herrie|Pre3: for udev, I don't know, maybe that's the default action
Feb 15 13:21:44 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: OK
Feb 15 13:26:37 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: Could you do a strace luna-next to see what happens when you start luna-next?
Feb 15 13:26:54 <Herrie|Laptop> I have a few missing bits in my strace, not sure these are critical and the cause for the gstreamer issue
Feb 15 13:27:28 <Herrie|Laptop> I have these missing: https://bpaste.net/show/e4a166b30e65
Feb 15 13:27:40 <Herrie|Laptop> LAst 2 files I copied to the location where it expects them, but still no luck
Feb 15 13:56:39 <Herrie|Laptop> bshah: You around?
Feb 15 14:09:45 <bshah> yo
Feb 15 14:11:20 <Herrie|Pre3> In my udev rules I seem to have a lot of users/groups that don't seem to exist. You know where these are defined/created?
Feb 15 14:11:42 <Herrie|Pre3> I tried searching Halium, UBPorts & LineageOS GitHub but little luck
Feb 15 14:11:42 <bshah> it's somewhere in yur rootfs creation I believe
Feb 15 14:11:52 <bshah> Tofe: might know
Feb 15 14:12:12 <Herrie|Pre3> Where you do it in Halium?
Feb 15 14:13:21 <bshah> in halium I do e.g. This :https://github.com/Halium/rootfs-builder/blob/ubuntu/customization/hooks/01-setup_user_group.chroot
Feb 15 14:13:39 <bshah> this is done at rootfs creation level
Feb 15 14:16:19 <Herrie|Laptop> Ok that helps :)
Feb 15 14:20:25 <Tofe> Herrie|Laptop: this is probably something that is done at the Yocto level
Feb 15 14:20:36 <Tofe> But I don't know where
Feb 15 14:20:42 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: I think I have a clue ;)
Feb 15 14:22:38 <Herrie|Laptop> Seems to come from base_passwd I guess
Feb 15 14:22:44 <Herrie|Laptop> We have this patch in meta-android: https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/base-passwd/base-passwd/change-android-group-ids.patch
Feb 15 14:24:14 <Herrie|Laptop> Which comes from https://github.com/openembedded/openembedded-core/blob/pyro/meta/recipes-core/base-passwd/base-passwd_3.5.29.bb which gets the following https://launchpad.net/debian/+archive/primary/+files/base-passwd_3.5.29.tar.gz
Feb 15 14:27:05 <Tofe> ok, yes, that must be it
Feb 15 14:27:24 <Herrie|Laptop> So I guess we need to do some patching there :P
Feb 15 14:28:13 <Herrie|Laptop> Additionally we might be able to do it here: https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system/android-system_1.0.bb#L37
Feb 15 14:29:09 <Herrie|Laptop> That would create the users, but not the groups I guess
Feb 15 14:38:54 <Herrie|Laptop> Tofe: We might want to have a look at this as well? https://github.com/shr-distribution/meta-smartphone/blob/pyro/meta-android/recipes-core/android-system-image/android-system-image.inc#L43
Feb 15 14:39:10 <Herrie|Laptop> References hal-droid
Feb 15 14:50:36 <Tofe> Herrie|Laptop: I'll go a general cleanup soon
Feb 15 14:58:43 <Herrie|Pre3> Tofe: Seems needed
Feb 15 14:58:56 <Herrie|Pre3> Not sure if these users cause issues or not
Feb 15 14:59:16 <Herrie|Pre3> Just going through logs now and fixing possible issues I see
Feb 15 16:55:16 <Herrie|Laptop> Seems there's a pretty extensive list here we could use: https://github.com/LineageOS/android_device_motorola_addison/blob/cm-14.1/include/private/android_filesystem_config.h#L45
Feb 15 16:55:28 <Herrie|Laptop> Even Halium guys are missing quite some it seems
Feb 15 16:56:02 <Herrie|Laptop> mer-hybris has some more: https://github.com/mer-hybris/hybris-initrd/blob/937e1a21214355a7b5cff33e90f47a43081ed9b1/etc/passwd
Feb 15 16:56:19 <Herrie|Laptop> Question is of course if we need all, but we can have a look & see for the targets which ones are required
Feb 15 16:56:46 <Herrie|Laptop> That should be fairly easy to grep from LineageOS, AOSP and CAF repos
Feb 15 18:05:18 <Herrie|Pre3> Tofe: I guess I could do a quick test where I simply add the missing users from my journalctl to see if that improves anything on logcat & luna-next side
Feb 15 18:35:04 <Tofe> Herrie|Pre3: https://paste2.org/pdVkpztJ test_sensors output on N5
Feb 15 18:35:41 <Tofe> But that's no surprise, it has always crashed.
Feb 15 18:38:07 <Tofe> and strace luna-next: https://paste2.org/XZk6wB4v
Feb 15 19:00:26 <Herrie> Tofe: Thnx
Feb 15 20:33:30 <Herrie> Tofe: You get QTI Sensors Module and 19 sensors ;) I don't get those ;)
Feb 15 21:21:06 <Tofe> oh.
Feb 15 21:39:41 <Herrie> I somehow managed to kill logcat :P
Feb 15 21:39:46 <Herrie> Time for a new image it seems
Feb 15 21:39:57 <Herrie> THat's for tomorrow
Feb 15 21:40:06 <Herrie> Also got Tenderloin building for overnight
Feb 15 21:40:19 <Herrie> Tomorrow at home so some time to play hopefully
Feb 15 21:41:23 <Herrie> gn8
**** ENDING LOGGING AT Fri Feb 16 03:00:01 2018