**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Tue May 17 02:59:58 2011 **** ENDING LOGGING AT Tue May 17 10:44:26 2011 **** BEGIN LOGGING AT Tue May 17 10:44:26 2011 **** ENDING LOGGING AT Tue May 17 10:45:25 2011 **** BEGIN LOGGING AT Tue May 17 10:45:53 2011 May 17 19:53:19 denkenz: ping May 17 19:53:57 aruravi: pong May 17 19:54:31 regarding the tones/announcements May 17 19:54:54 what is AudioSettings interface used for? May 17 19:55:35 Why that can't be used for tones/announcements too? May 17 19:56:54 AudioSettings is really meant to tell the audio framework about the audio stream state, e.g. whether it is active and the mode May 17 19:57:57 Tones are frequently part of the audio stream on the modem itself May 17 19:58:25 And how one generates them is so highly modem specific it isn't funny May 17 19:59:54 I didn't get, does that mean AudioSettings interface cannot be used? how? May 17 20:06:27 So lets start over, what are you trying to accomplish? May 17 20:08:20 ok, was testing some use cases in meego, where when dialed to a non valid/terminated connection there are some announcements coming while the call is in the dialing state itself. How can this be handled? May 17 20:09:04 Now there is no way this announcement can be given to the user. May 17 20:10:11 This announcement, i belive comes from the PROGRESS indication. May 17 20:13:33 So the way this is supposed to be done is that the audio settings atom sets the Active property to true May 17 20:13:50 And the audio framework plays the audio from the modem automagically May 17 20:13:58 oFono has nothing to do here May 17 20:14:26 It simply reflects whether the modem has an audio stream active or not May 17 20:15:38 so the AudioSettings interface is indeed the place right.? May 17 20:16:03 Define 'the place'? The current API is about as much as you're going to get May 17 20:17:37 what i meant, is AudioSettings interface is were the tones/announcements will be handled, by setting the active property to true, if the required event is reported from modem. May 17 20:19:50 ah, then yes May 17 20:20:26 that was my doubt.. May 17 20:20:58 but you said ofono has nothing to do here.. May 17 20:21:26 You were pretty vague on 'tone generation' May 17 20:21:38 There are modems that can generate side-tones, e.g. call waiting alerts, battery alerts May 17 20:22:23 That is a topic all of its own, different from audio stream being active or not May 17 20:22:53 ha.. sorry, but i did say "In band" .. May 17 20:24:14 exactly, if you want to generate those tones via AT commands, then that is outside of scope of oFono core May 17 20:24:39 hence my reply May 17 20:26:54 no that was not my case...may be i mislead you... May 17 20:27:59 no worries, we figured it out in the end May 17 20:28:15 However, what you have in mind is no different from regular call audio ;) May 17 20:29:12 :) May 17 20:31:40 i just tested the caller tones feature, where instead of regular "ring" "ring", some song can be played. This works fine, but this happens after the call has entered the alerting state. May 17 20:32:29 For the case i mentioned (invalid number), the announcement is not heard... May 17 20:33:26 I'm probably going to be of little help here, I never thought AudioSettings was a terribly good idea May 17 20:33:46 The latency is too high May 17 20:34:06 I'd check with the audio policy guys or guys who wrote the audio-settings ifx driver May 17 20:34:20 ok.. May 17 20:35:11 may be there are provisions because for ifx, the there are many values of May 17 20:35:26 +XPROGRESS May 17 20:35:49 which could be giving indication of this..just a hunch.. May 17 20:36:07 don't know anything of that sort in isi May 17 20:40:57 yep, I'm lost in ISI May 17 20:41:35 And I don't think the IFX audio settings implementation was fully finished May 17 20:41:49 There was still some back and forth last time I paid attention May 17 20:41:58 ok **** ENDING LOGGING AT Wed May 18 02:59:57 2011