**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Tue Nov 13 02:59:57 2012
Nov 13 18:04:16 <PaulFertser> Hm, i wonder how fsogsmd is supposed to be loaded. When i simply request GSM from fsousaged, it says it was never registered.
Nov 13 18:04:29 <PaulFertser> What and when is usually dbus-activating or explicitely loading it?
Nov 13 18:05:05 <GNUtoo-x60> on debian?
Nov 13 18:05:14 <GNUtoo-x60> does debian uses systemd or sysvinit?
Nov 13 18:06:53 <PaulFertser> GNUtoo-x60: on SHR
Nov 13 18:07:26 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 18:07:34 <GNUtoo-x60> let me ssh and look
Nov 13 18:09:25 <GNUtoo-x60> PaulFertser, sorry it's not started by systemd
Nov 13 18:09:29 <GNUtoo-x60> probably by dbus then
Nov 13 18:11:07 <PaulFertser> GNUtoo-x60: yes, it might be. But something should be trying to use org.freesmartphone.ogsmd then.
Nov 13 18:11:13 <PaulFertser> I wonder what does it.
Nov 13 18:11:59 <GNUtoo-x60> hmmm
Nov 13 18:12:06 <GNUtoo-x60> maybe SHR deamons
Nov 13 18:15:31 <morphis> GNUtoo-x60: yes, the SHR daemons are requesting the GSM resource
Nov 13 18:15:44 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 18:16:33 <PaulFertser> morphis: what do you mean? When i try to request GSM fsodeviced just tells me it was never registered.
Nov 13 18:17:10 <morphis> PaulFertser: fsousaged should list the GSM resource
Nov 13 18:17:32 <morphis> it depends wether the shadow resource feature is enabled or not
Nov 13 18:17:45 <morphis> if it is then fsousaged will activate fsogsmd through dbus
Nov 13 18:17:57 <morphis> if not somebody else has to activate fsogsmd
Nov 13 18:18:02 <PaulFertser> morphis: ah, shadow resource feature, right.
Nov 13 18:18:08 <PaulFertser> morphis: it seems to be disabled by default
Nov 13 18:18:34 <PaulFertser> morphis: it's too long i was working with FSO, have absolutely forgotten about the shadow resource feature.
Nov 13 18:18:35 <morphis> yes
Nov 13 18:18:39 <morphis> :)
Nov 13 18:19:54 <PaulFertser> morphis: thanks!
Nov 13 18:20:31 <morphis> np
Nov 13 18:30:16 <GNUtoo-x60> PaulFertser, what's the shadow resource?
Nov 13 18:32:38 <PaulFertser> GNUtoo-x60: it's a special trick to have fso daemons auto-activated when something requests them from fsousaged.
Nov 13 18:33:27 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 18:59:21 <PaulFertser> morphis: on my system it got compiled the way that ${datarootdir}/dbus-1/system-services is used to search for the shadow resources, and also i notice none of the supplied configs uses that option.
Nov 13 18:59:49 <PaulFertser> I mean literally
Nov 13 19:04:57 <PaulFertser> In the generated Makefile DBUS_SYSTEM_SERVICE_DIR goes before datarootdir = ${prefix}/share so no wonder.
Nov 13 19:09:32 <PaulFertser> GNUtoo-x60: now pushed another improvements to fso-el, you can even easily run it on your host and access the phone via dbus-proxy-daemon 
Nov 13 19:09:52 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 19:09:53 <GNUtoo-x60> nice
Nov 13 19:11:12 <PaulFertser> I'm not sure what Emacs version to recommend though. Emacs24 in Debian unstable misses signals but self-built today version works fine.
Nov 13 19:11:24 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 19:12:39 <PaulFertser> And Emacs23 doesn't allow to specify custom dbus address, so with dbus-proxy-daemon you'll need to run the whole Emacs prosses with a special env variable and specify :session bus for fso.el
Nov 13 19:19:02 <PaulFertser> On gta04 emacs is fast anyway so it's easier to run it on device itself.
Nov 13 19:25:18 <PaulFertser> GNUtoo-x60: it looks like the only way fsogsmd can properly establish "data service" is when fsonetworkd running...
Nov 13 19:25:23 <PaulFertser> I'm not sure i like that.
Nov 13 19:26:13 <GNUtoo-x60> hmmm
Nov 13 19:46:15 <PaulFertser> I mean is that an official FSO policy?
Nov 13 19:50:32 <PaulFertser> I mean people often like to run other network managers and that would probably not play along well etc.
Nov 13 20:09:53 <slyon> hey!
Nov 13 20:10:15 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, were you able to try the headset stuff yesterday?
Nov 13 20:23:59 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, not yet
Nov 13 20:24:27 <slyon> ok
Nov 13 20:31:32 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, opkg upgrading now
Nov 13 20:40:54 <slyon> cool :)
Nov 13 20:50:48 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, strange....I've still the init wich asks me to choose between nand and microsd
Nov 13 20:51:08 <GNUtoo-x60> Linux om-gta04 3.4.9 #1 PREEMPT Tue Nov 13 00:07:03 CET 2012 armv7l GNU/Linux
Nov 13 20:56:22 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, hmm. that's strange... I've defenitely removed gta04-init: http://git.shr-project.org/git/?p=meta-smartphone.git;a=commit;h=8b81a1be326117acc3f2c7e15cc79acdd70baf17
Nov 13 20:56:35 <GNUtoo-x60> yes
Nov 13 20:56:39 <GNUtoo-x60> and I have that commit
Nov 13 20:57:40 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, do you have the "Voice route" alsa control in alsamixer?
Nov 13 20:58:07 <GNUtoo-x60> how to grep that?
Nov 13 20:59:24 <GNUtoo-x60> amixer list or something?
Nov 13 20:59:33 <slyon> it's just amixer
Nov 13 20:59:34 <GNUtoo-x60> ah yes
Nov 13 20:59:38 <slyon> without parameters
Nov 13 20:59:45 <GNUtoo-x60> there is also alsactl -f foo store
Nov 13 20:59:47 <GNUtoo-x60> vim foo
Nov 13 20:59:49 <slyon> yes
Nov 13 21:00:08 <GNUtoo-x60> Simple mixer control 'Voice route',0
Nov 13 21:00:52 <slyon> hmm do you have another system installed?
Nov 13 21:01:04 <slyon> afaik gta04-init does some symlinking magic
Nov 13 21:01:17 <slyon> maybe it started with an older/other kernel and then booted the new one?
Nov 13 21:02:12 <GNUtoo-x60> maybe
Nov 13 21:02:20 <GNUtoo-x60> anyway I want to try the patches
Nov 13 21:03:04 <slyon> yes. but as "Voice route" is available you should be able to test my fsodeviced
Nov 13 21:03:12 <GNUtoo-x60> yes
Nov 13 21:10:41 <GNUtoo-x60> now what should I test?
Nov 13 21:13:58 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, trying to play sound, using the 'headset' scenario
Nov 13 21:14:13 <slyon> and trying to make a call, using the 'gsmheadset' scenario
Nov 13 21:14:45 <slyon> i assume you'll have noise using 'gsmheadset' then you'd need to flip the AVADC Clock priority control
Nov 13 21:14:55 <GNUtoo-x60> I've no noise
Nov 13 21:15:04 <GNUtoo-x60> or very minor maybe
Nov 13 21:15:27 <slyon> OK. even better. using gsmhandset I had very loud noise in the background
Nov 13 21:15:30 <GNUtoo-x60> how does the noise looks like?
Nov 13 21:15:47 <GNUtoo-x60> should I push audio on my router?
Nov 13 21:16:03 <GNUtoo-x60> paulk had noise long time ago too
Nov 13 21:16:31 <GNUtoo-x60> because there is noise
Nov 13 21:16:36 <GNUtoo-x60> but the voice is way louder
Nov 13 21:16:41 <slyon> which router?
Nov 13 21:17:19 <GNUtoo-x60> ah ouch 
Nov 13 21:17:24 <GNUtoo-x60> wait one second
Nov 13 21:17:28 <GNUtoo-x60> I've noise
Nov 13 21:17:40 <GNUtoo-x60> arecord -r 8000 -c 1 > rec.wav => noise
Nov 13 21:17:59 <GNUtoo-x60> arecord -f cd > cd.wav => very minor noise
Nov 13 21:18:31 <slyon> hmm i'm not sure about arecord...
Nov 13 21:18:40 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:18:41 <slyon> afaik the AVADC has something to do with the modem
Nov 13 21:18:43 <GNUtoo-x60> what should I do?
Nov 13 21:18:46 <GNUtoo-x60> real calls?
Nov 13 21:18:52 <slyon> so i think it should be tested in a call
Nov 13 21:18:53 <slyon> yes
Nov 13 21:19:00 <slyon> like calling the mailbox or something
Nov 13 21:19:34 <GNUtoo-x60> note that it stiill jumps a bit back and forth between headset and normal during calls
Nov 13 21:19:52 <GNUtoo-x60> I ear nothing during that call
Nov 13 21:19:57 <GNUtoo-x60> before I did ear something
Nov 13 21:20:04 <GNUtoo-x60> and forwarder is fixed
Nov 13 21:20:06 <GNUtoo-x60> ah wait a bit
Nov 13 21:20:11 <GNUtoo-x60> maybe not in your branch
Nov 13 21:20:22 <slyon> i've rebased. should include you latest stuff
Nov 13 21:20:51 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:20:56 <GNUtoo-x60> fsoaudiod is still there
Nov 13 21:20:58 <GNUtoo-x60> but I do:
Nov 13 21:21:01 <GNUtoo-x60> 4242 => works
Nov 13 21:21:06 <GNUtoo-x60> 4200 => fails
Nov 13 21:22:07 <GNUtoo-x60> voice route should be set to something?
Nov 13 21:22:09 <GNUtoo-x60> to twl?
Nov 13 21:22:11 <GNUtoo-x60> to SOC?
Nov 13 21:22:50 <slyon> it should be set to SoC for swrouting
Nov 13 21:22:55 <slyon> and to twl for hwrouting
Nov 13 21:23:33 <slyon> but it should be set to SOC in the gsmheadset scenario
Nov 13 21:23:58 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:25:21 <slyon> maybe this has something to do with this strange bug, the people on gta04-owner complain about for QtMoko where the sound card is kept open, so no other sound can be played?
Nov 13 21:25:39 <GNUtoo-x60> no idea but we fixed that long ago in SHR
Nov 13 21:25:45 <slyon> ok
Nov 13 21:25:54 <GNUtoo-x60> it was ringing
Nov 13 21:25:58 <GNUtoo-x60> and no sound during call
Nov 13 21:26:03 <GNUtoo-x60> but here it's not ringing
Nov 13 21:26:06 <GNUtoo-x60> and it's fixed already
Nov 13 21:26:09 <GNUtoo-x60> since ages
Nov 13 21:26:35 <slyon> ok. so it shouldn't be that problem
Nov 13 21:27:49 <slyon> hmm. but was the sound OK when you called 4242?
Nov 13 21:28:07 <GNUtoo-x60> wow I know why it jumps
Nov 13 21:28:09 <GNUtoo-x60> [ 1210.239990] twl4030_madc twl4030_madc: conversion timeout!
Nov 13 21:28:25 <GNUtoo-x60> that's a very usefull info
Nov 13 21:28:35 <GNUtoo-x60> yes
Nov 13 21:28:37 <slyon> wow. nice find!
Nov 13 21:28:39 <GNUtoo-x60> but I don't record
Nov 13 21:28:49 <GNUtoo-x60> oops
Nov 13 21:28:51 <GNUtoo-x60> I meant:
Nov 13 21:29:05 <GNUtoo-x60> on 4242 the remote is only a dumb interactive menu
Nov 13 21:29:15 <GNUtoo-x60> it doesn't feed you back your voice
Nov 13 21:29:58 <slyon> that should be OK... I had the noise in the background of my dumb mailbox menu, not on my own speech
Nov 13 21:32:41 <GNUtoo-x60> no I mean that I want my speech back
Nov 13 21:32:49 <GNUtoo-x60> like the echo in asterisk
Nov 13 21:32:58 <GNUtoo-x60> like call 500 and get your voice back in asterisk
Nov 13 21:33:26 <slyon> yes, i know what you mean.
Nov 13 21:34:27 <slyon> just my noise-problem wasn't on my own voice, but on the sound i heard from the other side
Nov 13 21:34:45 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:34:54 <GNUtoo-x60> hmmm
Nov 13 21:34:59 <GNUtoo-x60> now what should I do?
Nov 13 21:35:01 <GNUtoo-x60> call you?
Nov 13 21:35:01 <slyon> so if this works for you (you hear no voice on in your earpiece/headset) it should be allright
Nov 13 21:35:14 <GNUtoo-x60> and you record me?
Nov 13 21:35:24 <GNUtoo-x60> or just ear me
Nov 13 21:35:25 <GNUtoo-x60> ?
Nov 13 21:36:06 <slyon> hmm if you like to
Nov 13 21:36:14 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:36:18 <GNUtoo-x60> what's your number?
Nov 13 21:36:22 <GNUtoo-x60> maybe PM it
Nov 13 21:43:14 <GNUtoo-x60> so summup of private conversation:
Nov 13 21:43:15 <GNUtoo-x60> no echo
Nov 13 21:43:21 <GNUtoo-x60> and no noise
Nov 13 21:43:26 <slyon> yes, on both sides
Nov 13 21:44:02 <slyon> but: slight delay (silence) at the beginning (few seconds)
Nov 13 21:45:00 <GNUtoo-x60> yes
Nov 13 21:45:03 <GNUtoo-x60> we should fix it
Nov 13 21:45:13 <GNUtoo-x60> also I've made a fix for the forwarder crash
Nov 13 21:45:19 <GNUtoo-x60> some days ago
Nov 13 21:45:36 <GNUtoo-x60> the glibc malloc/calloc/free etc... failures
Nov 13 21:46:25 <slyon> yeah. that fix you did is really important
Nov 13 21:47:45 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:47:50 <GNUtoo-x60> for A3....
Nov 13 21:48:11 <slyon> yes
Nov 13 21:48:44 <GNUtoo-x60> what you did for A4 is even more important
Nov 13 21:48:54 <GNUtoo-x60> because way more people have > A3 than A3
Nov 13 21:50:33 <slyon> yes. now that my hwrouting work seems to work, I'll switch hwrouting on by default. and we A3 users will have to disable the extra_path option in fsodeviced.conf. OK?
Nov 13 21:51:50 <GNUtoo-x60> can't we make out of the box work for both?
Nov 13 21:53:32 <GNUtoo-x60> what does /proc/cpuinfo says for > A3 ?
Nov 13 21:53:40 <slyon> that would be possible too, but i'd need to hack device specific code into the generic alsa_router plugin then...
Nov 13 21:53:56 <GNUtoo-x60> because we have that on fsodeviced:
Nov 13 21:53:59 <GNUtoo-x60> mdbus2 -s org.freesmartphone.odeviced /org/freesmartphone/Device/Info org.freesmartphone.Device.Info.GetCpuInfo
Nov 13 21:54:05 <GNUtoo-x60> hmmm
Nov 13 21:54:31 <GNUtoo-x60> since it's vala can't we extends the standard class?
Nov 13 21:54:39 <GNUtoo-x60> but if you want to push, push
Nov 13 21:55:40 <slyon> it looked like the cleanest method to me... there are just ~20 A3s out there... so those people would need to disable "extra_path" after installation
Nov 13 21:55:51 <slyon> i'll document this on the installtion page
Nov 13 21:56:02 <slyon> (in our trac wiki)
Nov 13 21:56:24 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 21:56:51 <jake42> slyon: GNUtoo-x60: hi
Nov 13 21:56:52 <GNUtoo-x60> buying a new GTA04 is not cheap for me tough
Nov 13 21:57:02 <GNUtoo-x60> so I'm improving the A3 to make it become usable for me
Nov 13 21:57:05 <GNUtoo-x60> hi jake42 
Nov 13 21:57:07 <slyon> morphis, the slyon/gta04-hwrouting branch seems to be working. if you're OK with it please merge it into master and into 0.12 branches
Nov 13 21:57:10 <slyon> hi jake42!
Nov 13 21:57:30 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, it's the same here. I don't have the money to buy a A4/A5
Nov 13 21:57:37 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, can you do the work for merging it to master?
Nov 13 21:58:30 <jake42> slyon: I stumbled upon your rework of the shr wikipage, I like it
Nov 13 21:58:37 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, it's just git merge slyon/gta04-hwrouting it will apply cleanly. but I'd like to have morphis to review it before.
Nov 13 21:58:48 <jake42> slyon: think we should make that the new one
Nov 13 21:58:56 <jake42> http://www.shr-project.org/trac/wiki/WikiStartNew
Nov 13 21:58:57 <GNUtoo-x60> ah ok
Nov 13 21:59:04 <slyon> jake42, yes i started it some time ago... it's not finished yet
Nov 13 21:59:20 <GNUtoo-x60> WOW
Nov 13 21:59:26 <slyon> jake42, if you want: go ahead and finish it and push it as our main page
Nov 13 21:59:29 <jake42> slyon: already looks alot better than the oldone
Nov 13 21:59:31 <GNUtoo-x60> I was just thinking that the front page needed to be updated
Nov 13 21:59:40 <GNUtoo-x60> like some hours ago
Nov 13 21:59:47 <jake42> GNUtoo-x60: :)
Nov 13 22:00:06 <GNUtoo-x60> but mainly it was about What is SHR
Nov 13 22:00:17 <GNUtoo-x60> because it lists some devices that we don't support anymore
Nov 13 22:00:53 <GNUtoo-x60> ah it's fixed in your version
Nov 13 22:00:58 <slyon> heh. but there are far too much links on that page. some of them should be removed or combined
Nov 13 22:01:05 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 22:01:11 <GNUtoo-x60> some links are for developers
Nov 13 22:01:49 <slyon> well. if you like it.... we could as well make it the default now and improve it afterwards
Nov 13 22:02:03 <GNUtoo-x60> yes I like it, but only if we don't loose content
Nov 13 22:02:17 <GNUtoo-x60> if nothing is lost merge it
Nov 13 22:06:47 <slyon> ok. i'll double check the links and merge it afterwards
Nov 13 22:07:30 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 22:07:37 <GNUtoo-x60> btw I've merged xv some time ago
Nov 13 22:08:01 <GNUtoo-x60> but I didn't find a way to make mplayer use it *and* fallback on X11 when it's not possible to use it
Nov 13 22:09:08 <GNUtoo-x60> the TODO here is nearly complete: http://wiki.freesmartphone.org/index.php/Hardware/GTA04 but still some stuff lacking
Nov 13 22:09:38 <GNUtoo-x60> I'll add gta04 A3 && > A3 detection in that list
Nov 13 22:11:05 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, we already can detect gta04a3
Nov 13 22:11:23 <slyon> we're doing this in the fsogsmd gta04 lowlevel plugin afaik
Nov 13 22:11:24 <GNUtoo-x60> in fso?
Nov 13 22:11:29 <GNUtoo-x60> ok nice
Nov 13 22:11:29 <slyon> yes
Nov 13 22:11:31 <GNUtoo-x60> let me look
Nov 13 22:11:51 <slyon> it's just checking if a specific gpio exists, which does only exist on gta04 >= a4
Nov 13 22:12:52 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, http://git.freesmartphone.org/?p=cornucopia.git;a=blob;f=fsogsmd/src/plugins/lowlevel_gta04/plugin.vala;h=736a66f4fcf28995dbea15ef0b0d97f034633726;hb=HEAD#l49
Nov 13 22:13:29 <GNUtoo-x60> yes I forgott about that
Nov 13 22:13:48 <GNUtoo-x60> thanks
Nov 13 22:14:53 <GNUtoo-x60> also what would be nice would be to complete sound handling for telephony:
Nov 13 22:15:01 <GNUtoo-x60>  Add gsmspeaker scenario
Nov 13 22:15:01 <GNUtoo-x60> Add more controls in /etc/libphoneui.conf 
Nov 13 22:15:18 <GNUtoo-x60> these 2 things have to be done as soon as possible I guess
Nov 13 22:15:43 <slyon> yes... with /etc/libphoneui.conf we have the problem of hwrouting control vs swrouting controls
Nov 13 22:16:17 <slyon> my idea was to use hwrouting controls as default and comment the swrouting controls, so we A3 user would have to uncomment them
Nov 13 22:18:04 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 22:20:05 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, why not doing a router_gta04?
Nov 13 22:20:13 <GNUtoo-x60> there was a router_palmpre
Nov 13 22:20:19 <GNUtoo-x60> I could look into it if you want
Nov 13 22:22:13 <GNUtoo-x60> ah sorry that was in fsoaudiod
Nov 13 22:24:07 <GNUtoo-x60> or maybe better
Nov 13 22:24:10 <slyon> here you go: http://www.shr-project.org/trac/wiki
Nov 13 22:24:14 <GNUtoo-x60> we do it in quirks
Nov 13 22:24:23 <GNUtoo-x60> nice thanks
Nov 13 22:24:51 <slyon> GNUtoo-x60, i thought about that as well.. but it would be a LOT of doublicate code... and the current solution is just a few lines of code
Nov 13 22:25:19 <GNUtoo-x60> in quirks it would work out of the box
Nov 13 22:25:27 <GNUtoo-x60> it would be clean(hopefully)
Nov 13 22:25:28 <slyon> if you think this would be better, we can still do it
Nov 13 22:25:39 <GNUtoo-x60> and it would use vala overrides etc... ont to ducplicate code
Nov 13 22:25:47 <GNUtoo-x60> *not to duplicate code
Nov 13 22:25:56 <slyon> sounds good
Nov 13 22:26:13 <GNUtoo-x60> the problem is the following: if we don't do it I'll end up with a non-working phone some day
Nov 13 22:26:20 <GNUtoo-x60> because I reinstall often
Nov 13 22:26:32 <GNUtoo-x60> and I will probably forget to delete the line
Nov 13 22:26:41 <slyon> but there would still be the problem with /etc/libphoneui.conf
Nov 13 22:26:51 <GNUtoo-x60> ah?
Nov 13 22:27:07 <slyon> hwrouting needs other controls there
Nov 13 22:27:35 <GNUtoo-x60> really?
Nov 13 22:27:46 <GNUtoo-x60> I didn't know that
Nov 13 22:28:10 <GNUtoo-x60> what kind of diff does it needs there?
Nov 13 22:28:25 <GNUtoo-x60> if it's that:
Nov 13 22:28:26 <GNUtoo-x60> -sw
Nov 13 22:28:27 <GNUtoo-x60> +hw
Nov 13 22:28:30 <slyon> http://paste.debian.net/209026/ that's jeepingben s libphoneui.conf
Nov 13 22:28:30 <GNUtoo-x60> should be ok
Nov 13 22:28:43 <GNUtoo-x60> if it's different at the volume control level it may be way harder
Nov 13 22:28:59 <GNUtoo-x60> DAC Voice Digital Downlink Volume
Nov 13 22:29:00 <GNUtoo-x60> ouch
Nov 13 22:30:26 <GNUtoo-x60> the problem is that we can't drop A3
Nov 13 22:30:34 <GNUtoo-x60> because all our devs have A3
Nov 13 22:30:43 <GNUtoo-x60> unless we both upgrade to A4?
Nov 13 22:30:45 <GNUtoo-x60> how?
Nov 13 22:31:08 <GNUtoo-x60> I've a way but it's quite long and complicated
Nov 13 22:31:28 <GNUtoo-x60> we ask morphis and JaMa to exchange our A3 against their A4
Nov 13 22:31:31 <GNUtoo-x60> or something like that
Nov 13 22:32:05 <GNUtoo-x60> else we detect and make work out of the box
Nov 13 22:33:01 <GNUtoo-x60> basically all the devs have A3 and all the potential users will have A4
Nov 13 22:33:05 <GNUtoo-x60> or more recent
Nov 13 22:33:07 <GNUtoo-x60> that's not good
Nov 13 22:33:10 <slyon> yes...
Nov 13 22:33:24 <slyon> a friend of mine will get an a4 soon
Nov 13 22:33:28 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 22:33:36 <slyon> he'll probably become a dev afterwards :)
Nov 13 22:33:40 <GNUtoo-x60> ok nice
Nov 13 22:34:24 <slyon> autodetection would work in FSO. but i think it's problematic in SHR (libphoneui), because libphoneui doen't have any infrastructure for such sort of things
Nov 13 22:34:50 <slyon> but we could still do an ugly device specific hack in libphoneui...
Nov 13 22:35:15 <GNUtoo-x60> yes
Nov 13 22:35:22 <slyon> but we would then somehow make sure, that there is no gpio186 on any other device...
Nov 13 22:35:24 <GNUtoo-x60> if you have an idea on how to do it in SHR?
Nov 13 22:35:31 <GNUtoo-x60> s/if/
Nov 13 22:35:50 <GNUtoo-x60> slyon, we could use fso for that
Nov 13 22:35:56 <GNUtoo-x60> like detect me the hw revision
Nov 13 22:36:04 <slyon> yes...
Nov 13 22:36:22 <slyon> that would be a good solution i think
Nov 13 22:38:20 <slyon> so what would be needed is this: define a "device revision/version" API
Nov 13 22:38:27 <slyon> implement this API
Nov 13 22:39:17 <slyon> create a gta04 specific alsa_router inherited from the generic alsa router
Nov 13 22:39:37 <slyon> adopt libphoneui to use the new FSO api to load different libphoneui.conf on a3 or a4+
Nov 13 22:40:10 <slyon> use that api in the gta04_alsa_router as well
Nov 13 22:47:37 <GNUtoo-x60> ok
Nov 13 22:47:41 <GNUtoo-x60> I'll go to sleep
Nov 13 22:47:46 <GNUtoo-x60> there is fsodeviced infos
Nov 13 22:48:07 <GNUtoo-x60> and devmem can work in userspace and get that revision
Nov 13 22:48:12 <GNUtoo-x60> *devmem2
Nov 13 22:48:36 <GNUtoo-x60> bye
Nov 13 23:00:20 <slyon> GNUtoo, btw: here is /proc/cpuinfo for gta04A3 and gta04A4, they are the same: http://lists.goldelico.com/pipermail/gta04-owner/2012-July/002609.html
Nov 13 23:00:42 <slyon> i'll leave now as well. bye!
**** ENDING LOGGING AT Wed Nov 14 02:59:59 2012