**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Thu Nov 13 03:00:00 2014 Nov 13 06:52:30 build #721 of xburst is complete: Failure [failed compile_8] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/xburst/builds/721 Nov 13 07:04:19 build #575 of octeon is complete: Failure [failed compile_5] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/octeon/builds/575 Nov 13 07:25:00 build #219 of adm8668 is complete: Failure [failed compile_5] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/adm8668/builds/219 Nov 13 07:30:04 build #210 of omap is complete: Failure [failed compile_4] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/omap/builds/210 Nov 13 11:39:34 <__trine> has anyone got an FTP server running on their own subnet to try a test please? Nov 13 17:31:47 any openwrt dev here that would like a free tplink archer c7 v2 in exchange to make it work more better with openwrt? :P Nov 13 17:39:48 nbd r43239 trunk/package/ (8 files) * ath9k: fix crashes when using shared IRQs Nov 13 17:54:38 _trine: I could set one up, what do you want to test? Nov 13 17:55:18 build #746 of ppc44x is complete: Failure [failed shell_10] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/ppc44x/builds/746 Nov 13 17:58:41 <_trine> karlp, that would be good Nov 13 17:58:56 <_trine> the problem is this Nov 13 17:59:44 <_trine> I cannot connect to my FTP server from the WAN side if I have QoS running,, without QoS running it works perfectly Nov 13 18:00:16 <_trine> I just wanted to confirm it was not me Nov 13 18:00:47 yeah, I don'thave a "wan/lan" setup, what do you really want to test? Nov 13 18:00:50 <_trine> I am running vsftpd on a dockstar on my lan Nov 13 18:01:04 are you trying to test firewall settings on wan/lan for openwrt or what? Nov 13 18:01:27 <_trine> I can connect to other frp servers which are not on my LAN Nov 13 18:01:38 <_trine> its not a FW setting Nov 13 18:02:09 <_trine> the FTP server only becomes non connectable when I have QoS running Nov 13 18:02:46 <_trine> with logread -f I can see the incoming session request but after that nothing Nov 13 18:06:16 so, you have an openwrt router, running ??? with lan/wan ports, and "qos" running, whatever that is, and you can do regular ftp from client pc on lan port to ftp server on wan port, but not from client pc on lan port to ftp server on lan port? Nov 13 18:07:07 is nf_conntrack_ftp loaded? Nov 13 18:08:11 <_trine> Devastator, I am not sure but would that stop FTP connections if I had QoS running because without QoS running it all works perfectly Nov 13 18:08:37 maybe qos unloads nf_conntrack_ftp?! Nov 13 18:20:23 <_trine> Devastator, nf_conntrack_ftp is not selected in my build Nov 13 18:21:21 _trine can you try with it loaded and see if it makes any difference? Nov 13 18:23:40 <_trine> well I think I would need to recompile it as its a kernel module Nov 13 18:24:32 or compile it separately, wouldn't it be kmod- something? Nov 13 18:25:38 <_trine> I am not sure,,, I am looking perhaps in the right place,,, in make kernel_menuconfig Nov 13 18:26:05 maybe if you build it as a module it will turn an ipk package Nov 13 18:27:49 nbd r43240 branches/barrier_breaker/package/ (11 files) * ath9k: fix crashes when using shared IRQs Nov 13 18:29:40 _trine the package you need is kmod-ipt-nathelper Nov 13 18:30:36 <_trine> thanks I will give that a try Nov 13 18:31:59 hum, wait, they are nat helpers, if you are talking about own subnet, you are not doing nat, and it won't help Nov 13 18:32:58 <_trine> if I try to connect to my FTP server over my LAN it connects ok regardless of QoS Nov 13 18:34:14 <_trine> I only have this problem if I try to connect from the WAN side Nov 13 18:34:32 hum, then the module might help Nov 13 18:34:34 <_trine> kmod-ipt-nathelper-rtsp >>>> is all I see Nov 13 18:35:09 <_trine> I see this as well >>> kmod-ipt-nat-extra Nov 13 18:35:10 _trine is this BB or trunk? Nov 13 18:35:15 <_trine> trunk Nov 13 18:35:37 <_trine> kmod-nf-nathelper-extra Nov 13 18:35:40 <_trine> and that Nov 13 18:35:44 try to compile nf_conntrack_ftp as module Nov 13 18:35:51 it should generate an ipk Nov 13 18:36:09 <_trine> I dont see nf_conntrack_ftp Nov 13 18:37:56 _trine one sec Nov 13 18:40:39 <_trine> FTP protocol support Nov 13 18:40:43 <_trine> I see that Nov 13 18:40:58 <_trine> in Core Netfilter Configuration Nov 13 18:41:12 _trine make menuconfig -> kernel modules -> netfilter extensions -> kmod-ipt-nathelper Nov 13 18:44:41 <_trine> kmod-ipt-nathelper does not exist Nov 13 18:45:18 <_trine> I see kmod-nf-nathelper Nov 13 18:45:33 <_trine> and I already have that compiled in Nov 13 18:46:13 <_trine> there is also kmod-nf-nathelper-extra Nov 13 18:46:24 <_trine> which I did not have selected Nov 13 18:47:13 <_trine> I dont understand why it all works perfectly without QoS Nov 13 18:47:28 <_trine> why should I need anything else Nov 13 18:47:39 <_trine> why should QoS stop FTP working Nov 13 19:20:48 _trine which platform is that? Nov 13 19:21:25 <_trine> kirkwood Nov 13 19:21:33 <_trine> dockstar Nov 13 19:22:25 <_trine> http://homepage.ntlworld.com/tenerifeworld/photo/20141113_152259.jpg Nov 13 19:25:40 _trine in BB there is this: https://downloads.openwrt.org/barrier_breaker/14.07/kirkwood/generic/packages/base/kmod-ipt-nathelper_3.10.49-1_kirkwood.ipk Nov 13 19:26:16 _trine unfortunately I don't have a trunk clone in hand Nov 13 19:26:22 <_trine> it isnt in trunk as far as I can see Nov 13 19:26:46 _trine have you followed this path? make menuconfig -> kernel modules -> netfilter extensions -> kmod-ipt-nathelper Nov 13 19:27:01 <_trine> I will look again Nov 13 19:30:12 <_trine> http://paste.debian.net/131647/ Nov 13 19:30:55 yep, for some reason it was removed from trunk I guess Nov 13 19:31:11 can you flash BB just for testing? Nov 13 19:31:49 <_trine> I dont want to do that really and its getting late in the day now Nov 13 19:33:41 ok Nov 13 19:40:29 <_trine> Devastator, if I run logread -f I can see the FTP request but it never gets further than that when I have QoS running Nov 13 19:40:49 <_trine> without QoS its perfect Nov 13 19:41:48 _trine you could try to diff "iptables-save -c > withoutqos" and "iptables-save -c > withqos" Nov 13 19:42:03 and see what rules qos adds to iptables ruleset Nov 13 19:45:35 <_trine> hmm I dont have diff installed on my router Nov 13 19:45:58 save, get it with scp and compare on your computer Nov 13 19:46:03 <_trine> if thats what you mean Nov 13 19:50:33 <_trine> http://paste.debian.net/131651/ without QoS Nov 13 19:50:39 <_trine> http://paste.debian.net/131652/ with QoS Nov 13 19:57:57 build #792 of orion is complete: Failure [failed compile_8] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/orion/builds/792 Nov 13 20:01:47 build #712 of sibyte is complete: Failure [failed shell_10] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/sibyte/builds/712 Nov 13 20:02:17 <_trine> http://paste.debian.net/131655/ Nov 13 20:05:20 _trine I have one good news and one bad Nov 13 20:05:27 which one you want first? Nov 13 20:05:41 <_trine> dont care Nov 13 20:06:25 good news, your iptables rules doesn't change with qos enabled, which means the module I suggested won't help Nov 13 20:06:46 bad news is I don't know where you could investigate this a little more Nov 13 20:07:20 <_trine> sounds like good and good Nov 13 20:12:59 <_trine> at least I can go to bed soon :P Nov 13 20:56:35 build #724 of avr32 is complete: Failure [failed compile_5] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/avr32/builds/724 Nov 14 00:52:12 build #744 of ar7 is complete: Failure [failed compile_8] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/ar7/builds/744 **** BEGIN LOGGING AT Fri Nov 14 01:14:24 2014 Nov 14 01:38:22 build #638 of iop32x is complete: Failure [failed shell_10] Build details are at http://buildbot.openwrt.org:8010/builders/iop32x/builds/638 **** ENDING LOGGING AT Fri Nov 14 03:00:00 2014