**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Thu Apr 07 02:59:59 2011 Apr 07 06:27:12 GrueMaster: Could you please action bug 746023? A lot of these patches introduce new functionality, and IMO need an FFE. Thanks. Apr 07 06:29:21 ogra_: ^^ if you could look into it as well, that would be ood, thanks. Apr 07 06:29:27 good Apr 07 07:18:38 TheMuso: I'll ping ogra_ or rsalveti in the morning. Apr 07 09:29:58 what's the status of pm in omap4? Apr 07 09:32:37 WIP Apr 07 09:33:46 there's a patch in maverick/omap4 related to pm, that makes the kernel panic whenever a cpu hotplugged Apr 07 09:33:50 but since i Apr 07 09:34:07 it's not done yet, i'll just revert it Apr 07 09:34:57 you should ask ndec for an update. I do think we've got hotplug working on panda in the linaro kernel. Apr 07 09:35:46 yep, it works there, in fact you don't have that patch there :) Apr 07 09:36:02 it's just in maverick, i think it's a leftover Apr 07 09:55:51 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/707003 Apr 07 09:55:54 here it is Apr 07 11:04:06 ndec, our audio guys arent actually happy with the amount of changes to alsa-lib Apr 07 11:14:44 ogra_, I'm here as well if I'm needed Apr 07 11:14:59 diwic, ah, cool Apr 07 11:16:04 ogra_, and, were there changes to alsa-lib? I thought it was just PA at this point. Apr 07 11:16:12 PA = pulseaudio Apr 07 11:17:04 well, the tarball doesnt seem to have PA patches at all Apr 07 11:17:16 i only see alsa Apr 07 11:17:34 ogra_, if you follow luke's link, you have three files, the top two I can't open, the third one has PA patches Apr 07 11:17:59 the "commit message" one ? Apr 07 11:18:23 yeah Apr 07 11:18:33 ah, the name is misleading :P Apr 07 11:18:40 havent opened that one at all Apr 07 11:18:59 urgh ! Apr 07 11:19:09 thats another 8 Apr 07 11:19:32 can you open the top two? Apr 07 11:20:26 hmm, they seem to be the same as in PA_UCM_patches.tar.gz Apr 07 11:20:57 weird Apr 07 11:22:59 aha, they're labeled .tar.gz but should be .tar.bz2 ...? Apr 07 11:23:12 i dont think they are zipped at all Apr 07 11:23:23 tar xvf should work Apr 07 11:23:50 (for all these files) Apr 07 11:26:38 so the "cofigfiles" (sp!) file, that's just config files, I'm not worried about those affecting anything else. It's the PA patches that worry me. Apr 07 11:27:29 yep Apr 07 11:27:32 same here Apr 07 11:29:27 ogra_, is TheMuso clear on what to apply? Because I'm not and that makes it difficult to review. Apr 07 11:30:01 diwic, i dont think he is, he didnt say anything but to add a FFE request to the bug Apr 07 11:30:46 diwic, i dont have more info than you can read on the bug and in the backlog of this channel Apr 07 11:31:37 though comment #3 somewhat indictaes he looked at all of them Apr 07 11:31:51 and just wants release team approval Apr 07 11:32:45 he doesnt question the quality there it seems Apr 07 11:34:45 No, I have only quickly glanced at them. I just think that there is enough new functionality here that we need to get the release team's ok. Apr 07 11:35:18 i dont have probs to get that OK, but kate will ask about the impact Apr 07 11:35:27 Yeah I know Apr 07 11:35:45 The tarballs are actually bzip2, but have the wrong extension. Apr 07 11:38:08 TheMuso, figured that out but it took a while :-) Apr 07 11:38:20 TheMuso, so are you clear on what to apply? Apr 07 11:39:28 diwic: I think so, they are ordered after all. I just need to wait for the refactored patch on the pulse list that you commented on. Apr 07 11:41:16 TheMuso, as for my comments on the PA mailing list, I just had a glance that the jack detection stuff as I'm interested in having that working for Oneiric. I didn't look much on the UCM stuff. Apr 07 11:42:25 TheMuso, would it be possible for you to make a feature branch or package (for the PA patches) which we can use for review and testing? Apr 07 11:47:47 diwic: Will do first thing tomorrow. I am online doing work on other projects this evening. Apr 07 11:51:23 ogra_: I'm sure you understand that I don't want to throw it in, without testing on non-Arm, non-TI, hardware. Apr 07 11:51:33 To make sure things don't break elsewhere. Apr 07 11:53:44 TheMuso, ok, i'll add that to the feature request then and will discuss with kate Apr 07 11:53:52 ok thanks Apr 07 11:54:29 But yeah, will get packages ready for testing first thing tomorrow morning. Apr 07 11:57:35 TheMuso, thanks. Apr 07 12:11:57 ogra_: diwic: TheMuso: the UCM patches we provided are PA patches only. the only requirement for alsa is to use 0.24 which has UCM support, and we already have it in natty Apr 07 12:12:25 ndec, could you clarify on which set of patches is the one to apply? Apr 07 12:12:28 ndec, well, the patchset in https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/alsa-lib/+bug/746023 is definitely a lot more than just PA Apr 07 12:13:12 ndec, if it would be possible to define the minimal amount of stuff to apply to make it work that would be great Apr 07 12:13:46 ogra_: my understanding is that all patches in the tar ball are PA patches. Apr 07 12:14:01 i dont think thats the case Apr 07 12:14:37 and its a total of 19 patches in two tarballs Apr 07 12:14:45 three tarballs Apr 07 12:14:50 plus 7 config files Apr 07 12:14:57 in another tarball Apr 07 12:15:10 I think all 19 patches are for PA but some of them are overlapping Apr 07 12:15:31 yeah, it seems the second tarball duplicates some of the patches from the first one Apr 07 12:15:53 and then there's the set posted on the PA mailing-list Apr 07 12:16:08 you can get confused for less ;-) Apr 07 12:16:14 which seems to differ again :) Apr 07 12:16:38 yeah, Apr 07 12:16:40 . Apr 07 12:16:41 ogra_: diwic: this a 6-patch series for PA which is sent upstream too (https://tango.0pointer.de/pipermail/pulseaudio-discuss/2011-April/009746.html) Apr 07 12:16:57 ndec, different patrches from whats in the tarballs apparently Apr 07 12:17:14 and as stated above the tarballs have more than 6 Apr 07 12:17:25 ogra_: the second tar ball has all the required PA patches. and it replaces the first tarball. that's what alejandro said in his email. Apr 07 12:17:37 hrm Apr 07 12:17:43 (not on the bug though) Apr 07 12:18:31 ndec, also the second set of patches is named UCM-patches-commit-message.tar.bz2 .... i didnt even bother to look for patches in it firstly Apr 07 12:18:32 ogra_: http://afuera.cortijodelrio.net/~ddiaz/paucm/UCM-patches-commit-message.tar.bz2 has all patches , and it's in PA only, no alsa. and http://afuera.cortijodelrio.net/~ddiaz/paucm/PA_UCM_cofigFiles.tar.gz is for the config files Apr 07 12:18:49 right, thats clear now Apr 07 12:18:59 ogra_: sorry about the confusion. alejandro is in mexico. he will be online soon i guess. Apr 07 12:19:07 ndec: is it known when TI will rebuild omap4-extras-multimedia deps to current natty level? Apr 07 12:19:17 hrw, post release Apr 07 12:19:37 hrw: hi! it's known that it won't be ready for 11.04 release day ;-) Apr 07 12:20:05 thanks Apr 07 12:20:14 ndec, ogra_, So what you want me to test and review is http://afuera.cortijodelrio.net/~ddiaz/paucm/UCM-patches-commit-message.tar.bz2 and *not* the PA mailinglist stuff and *not* the tarball named "PA_UCM_patches.tar.gz" Apr 07 12:20:17 hrw: however the GFX package will be ready (and is already). so i guess that if you asked it's because you care about 1080p... Apr 07 12:20:29 so will not have a need to switch monitor on ;D Apr 07 12:21:04 diwic: the UCM-patches-commit-message tarball should contain the same series as sent to PA ML + a 2 other patches. that's what needs to be reviewed Apr 07 12:21:15 ndec: just spotted omap4 extras and wanted to check status Apr 07 12:21:29 hrw, the GLES drivers should be ready Apr 07 12:21:30 hrw: understand. Apr 07 12:21:37 the rest will be missing until post release Apr 07 12:22:08 ndec, they differ. Apr 07 12:22:22 ogra_: hrw: wlan will be ready for 11.04 release since we switch to mac802.11 stack, and since our firmware for panda is in linux-firmware package with no license restriction. Apr 07 12:22:27 diwic: a lot? Apr 07 12:22:59 diwic: i didn't check anything myself.. but alejandro from my team worked on this. Apr 07 12:24:38 ndec, e g, in patch 5/6, the function jack_insert_new_hook_callback differs, in the tarball, it's a stub, in the PA mailinglist, it seems to contain test code. Neither looks like good enough to release. Apr 07 12:25:14 diwic: ok. i would guess this part could be skipped maybe Apr 07 12:27:13 will it still work with only 1-4 applied ? Apr 07 12:27:35 unlikely Apr 07 12:27:53 well, i'm taking about general sound output ;) Apr 07 12:27:59 vs no sound at all Apr 07 12:28:41 jack detection seems to me like something i should be able to select in the audio settings still Apr 07 12:28:54 even if no autodetection is there Apr 07 12:28:57 5/6 is the big patch of them Apr 07 12:29:18 diwic: ok sorry.. 5 is required. what I meant is jack detect support is not needed to get sound. Apr 07 12:30:23 let's wait for Mexico to wake up to clarify this a bit further Apr 07 12:30:31 yes Apr 07 12:30:38 or Margarita if she's available Apr 07 12:31:01 ndec, whats her IRC nick, do you know ? Apr 07 12:32:46 ogra_: i forgot... but i will send an email to her and alejandro Apr 07 12:32:55 great, thanks Apr 07 12:37:03 ogra_, fwiw, if basic output is what's needed you can just call alsaucm to set the right ucm profile. No PA patches necessary Apr 07 12:39:23 hey ndec hows life in Nice? Apr 07 12:43:39 don't we have a natty's omap4 image somewhere? Apr 07 12:45:39 ppisati, we have two, what do you need, headless/serial or netbook ? Apr 07 12:46:04 uhm... both? :) Apr 07 12:46:24 diwic, hmm, so only the config files would be needed and pulse would magically work ? Apr 07 12:47:19 ppisati, http://cdimage.ubuntu.com/ubuntu-netbook/releases/natty/beta-1/ and http://cdimage.ubuntu.com/ubuntu-headless/releases/natty/beta-1/ Apr 07 12:47:45 ppisati, note the latter has no graphical output at all, the former has no serial Apr 07 12:48:11 ppisati, and two directory levels higher there are also daily builds Apr 07 12:48:18 ogra_: k, thanks Apr 07 12:49:00 i want to tackle the "X turn off" bug now Apr 07 12:49:16 then you should use netbook Apr 07 12:49:29 headless will need you to install a ton of stuff first Apr 07 12:49:35 with maverick i can't get it, and the upgrade process was PAINFULL (18 hrs!!!) Apr 07 12:49:38 yep Apr 07 12:49:45 i'll add serial to netbook Apr 07 12:49:49 yeah, the SD speed is far from optimal Apr 07 12:49:54 yep Apr 07 12:50:02 and from time to time it seems it goes in pm mode Apr 07 12:50:15 the SD ? Apr 07 12:50:24 if i leave it idle for a bit, and then issue an "ls" it takes many seconds to spit the output Apr 07 12:50:38 weird, anyting in dmesg ? Apr 07 12:50:38 dunno if the SD or anything else, but it's noticeable Apr 07 12:50:45 uhm Apr 07 12:50:46 no Apr 07 12:51:26 actually yes Apr 07 12:51:33 the video/hdmi goes in pm mode Apr 07 12:51:44 i know there were issues in the past if read and write occured at the same time Apr 07 12:51:53 wrt SD cards Apr 07 12:52:05 uhm no Apr 07 12:52:13 nothing regarding i/o, sd, etcetc Apr 07 12:52:14 the video shouldnt impact the SD IO Apr 07 12:52:57 the sync lost bug is an old one from maverick, given we use a forward ported graphics driver its no wonder if it exposes the same bug Apr 07 12:53:36 let's see Apr 07 12:54:02 the other one "high memory instabilities", well, i can't reproduce it in any way Apr 07 12:54:23 i left my panda compile for more than 5+ hrs, but no problem Apr 07 12:54:46 with a default unmodified ubuntu image ? Apr 07 12:56:29 yep, maverick image with latest natty kernel Apr 07 12:56:45 lp633227 Apr 07 12:56:47 strange, but i heard its hard to reproduce Apr 07 12:56:52 yep Apr 07 12:56:54 i know the bug :) Apr 07 12:57:01 the real problem is that we can't get a: Apr 07 12:57:06 a) quick way to reproduce it Apr 07 12:57:12 b) a reliable way to reproduce it Apr 07 12:57:16 it's like chasing ghost Apr 07 12:57:24 well, in the past we didnt have issues with a) Apr 07 12:57:34 it died pretty early iirc Apr 07 12:57:42 seems that changed with natty Apr 07 12:58:02 but it was never reliable Apr 07 12:58:20 what good is a reliable bug :-) we would all be out of jobs Apr 07 12:58:31 haha Apr 07 12:58:51 well, but when you can reproduce it, then real fun starts :) Apr 07 12:59:24 also hard to repeat bugs are good for hang over days Apr 07 12:59:47 i hate hang over days :) Apr 07 12:59:58 depends on the evenig really Apr 07 13:00:08 some are worth a good hangover ;) Apr 07 13:01:03 its always good to sleep at desk then tell your boss your trying to repeat really hard to repeat bug X :-D Apr 07 13:01:29 * ogra_ woud be surprised to see his boss at his desk though ;) Apr 07 13:01:31 ogra_, so assume we didn't take the patches at all, I guess you could get output would be to write a PulseAudio profile instead. Apr 07 13:01:53 that would not be invasive and would guarantee to not affect anything else Apr 07 13:01:57 diwic, automatically with only calling one command ? Apr 07 13:02:54 i could do that chrooted from jasper-iniramfs (our first boot tool) Apr 07 13:06:52 ogra_, I don't know UCM syntax so I'm a little unsure if PA profiles support everything that UCM does Apr 07 13:07:15 well, the question is if PA will ick it up at all without patches Apr 07 13:07:27 calling alsaucm is surely no prob Apr 07 13:09:40 * ogra_ goes to set up his panda for testing that Apr 07 13:21:24 diwic, hmm, intresting, i cnt even install alsa-utils on my panda, seems there is an issue with the postinst Apr 07 13:22:19 Setting up alsa-utils (1.0.24.2-0ubuntu3) ... Apr 07 13:22:19 dpkg: error: --compare-versions takes three arguments: Apr 07 13:22:22 hmpf Apr 07 13:22:38 comparing against a former version if there was none ... Apr 07 13:24:15 ogra_, hmm, haven't seen that one before Apr 07 13:24:43 well, i use a headless image as a base, that doesnt have anything more than ubuntu-minimal installed Apr 07 13:24:47 ogra_: same here. upgrading of alsa-utils works fine, install fails Apr 07 13:24:53 yeah Apr 07 13:25:06 if dpkg --compare-versions $2 lt 1.0.24.2-0ubuntu1 ; then Apr 07 13:25:18 seems $2 is empty on fresh installations Apr 07 13:25:26 (thats from the postinst) Apr 07 13:25:55 diwic, anyway, thats not what i wanted to test... see below: Apr 07 13:25:57 ogra@panda:~$ alsaucm Apr 07 13:25:57 No card found Apr 07 13:25:57 ogra@panda:~$ cat /proc/asound/cards Apr 07 13:25:57 0 [SDP4430 ]: SDP4430 - SDP4430 Apr 07 13:25:57 TI OMAP4 SDP4430 Board Apr 07 13:26:13 so not working OOTB Apr 07 13:26:33 confirmed Apr 07 13:26:47 ogra_, try installing the config files if they're not there Apr 07 13:26:49 same goes for the listcards command Apr 07 13:27:39 Hi guys, hows the PA UCM working for you? Apr 07 13:27:56 ogra@panda:/$ ls usr/share/alsa/ucm/SDP4430/ Apr 07 13:27:56 FMAnalog hifi hifiLP record SDP4430.conf voice voiceCall Apr 07 13:27:56 ogra@panda:/$ alsaucm Apr 07 13:27:56 Im setting defaults Apr 07 13:27:56 ogra@panda:/$ alsaucm listcards Apr 07 13:27:57 Im setting defaults Apr 07 13:27:59 0: SDP4430 Apr 07 13:28:01 ogra@panda:/$ Apr 07 13:28:05 diwic, that seems to do something Apr 07 13:28:14 (no desktop installed on that image though) Apr 07 13:28:32 alejandro-gm, hi there, I'm not even sure what patches to test Apr 07 13:28:39 alejandro-gm, hey, good to see you, we are fighting with the patches atm, diwic is one of our audio gusy Apr 07 13:28:48 *guys Apr 07 13:28:59 * hrw rebuilds alsa-utils Apr 07 13:29:30 ogra_, can you file a bug against alsa-utils for the dpkg problem Apr 07 13:29:31 what patches? I'm not sure what do you mean? Apr 07 13:29:31 rootfs on my panda is 5.3GB now Apr 07 13:29:37 diwic, will do Apr 07 13:30:07 I have ugly postinst change which want to test first Apr 07 13:30:13 alejandro-gm, we have three sets of patches to choose from, two different tarballs and one posted to the ML Apr 07 13:30:43 alejandro-gm, final freeze of ubuntu is on monday, initially we were told we would only get configs and two patches for panda to make sound work, now we are struggling with the amount of patches you provide and try to shrink down the patchset to at least get approval for a minimal set to get soujnd working Apr 07 13:31:08 else it wont make the release at all Apr 07 13:31:25 diwic: ho, ok, well they are all basically the same, but the ones I send are rebased for the 0.9.22 PA version Apr 07 13:31:28 alejandro-gm, have these patches been tested against non omap hardware at all ?` Apr 07 13:31:47 and the ones on the PA mailing list are on a more updated PA version Apr 07 13:32:22 ogra_ : as far as I know, yes, Margarita do the implementation on x86 Apr 07 13:32:25 alejandro-gm, at this late time of release we need to be 100% sure it doesnt break the x86 world Apr 07 13:33:06 alejandro-gm, e g, in patch 5/6, the function jack_insert_new_hook_callback differs: in the tarball, it's a stub, in the PA mailinglist, it seems to contain test code. Neither looks like good enough to release... Apr 07 13:34:34 diwic: mmmm, let me look at it, it may be referring to 'new' PA features (added after 0.9.22) Apr 07 13:35:56 alejandro-gm, for this particular thing also see https://tango.0pointer.de/pipermail/pulseaudio-discuss/2011-April/009758.html Apr 07 13:37:16 diwic, bug 753544 for you Apr 07 13:37:30 * ogra_ slaps the bot Apr 07 13:37:31 ogra_: http://paste.ubuntu.com/590766/ is fix Apr 07 13:37:36 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/alsa-utils/+bug/753544 Apr 07 13:37:42 hrw, add it to the bug ;) Apr 07 13:37:49 will do Apr 07 13:37:53 thx Apr 07 13:39:06 added patch, tagged patch, confirmed Apr 07 13:40:49 ogra_: final freeze == no new uploads for all repos? Apr 07 13:41:09 hrw, only with exceptions and your bug needs to be very very serious to get one Apr 07 13:41:31 and no NEW packages? Apr 07 13:41:59 not sure about universe but usually not Apr 07 13:43:05 I have two packages waiting for me to get upload rights - so probably one_eric will see them Apr 07 13:43:25 well, its actually not final freeze but beta2 freeze which turns into final freeze three days later Apr 07 13:43:55 so there is a small window where you can upload stuff that doesnt affect the images Apr 07 13:54:03 diwic: It looks to me that the patches on the mailist and the ones on the tarball differ only on some alignment (new lines and spaces), can you point me to the code you identify to be missing please? Apr 07 13:58:48 alejandro-gm, http://afuera.cortijodelrio.net/~ddiaz/paucm/UCM-patches-commit-message.tar.bz2 - v2/0005-alsa-create-ucm-profiles.patch, row 736, function jack_insert_new_hook_callback is a stub Apr 07 13:59:19 alejandro-gm, in total, that function is 8 lines and only outputs a debug message Apr 07 14:02:29 alejandro-gm, compare that to https://tango.0pointer.de/pipermail/pulseaudio-discuss/2011-April/009758.html where the same function is 25-30 lines Apr 07 14:02:56 diwic: regarding the PA discussion, what I can tell is 1) need to look at the 'pa_hook_cb_t' definition I couldn't find it at fist glance but it may be overloaded, otherwise I really dobut it would compile in any environment. 2) about the match card-event, every card has its own set of events and in PA each sink/source is attached to one card so I doubt there could be a conflict on that, but I'll ask Margarita, she has a setup with more than one Apr 07 14:02:57 card. 3) Headset is the device the UC is attached to the '.0' is the identifier, you may have more than one, but here the are using it only a default in case there is no device specified Apr 07 14:07:55 alejandro-gm, for 2) the hook is fired with an additional parameter containing the card to attach to but that is ignored due to 1). Apr 07 14:08:48 alejandro-gm, in 3) how do you specify a device Apr 07 14:13:39 diwic: this jack_insert_new_hook_callback function confuse me, let me see what goes wrong, or why it is this way on the patch of the tarball Apr 07 14:14:36 diwic: you specify the device of the UC on the configuration files, there is a file per verb=UC Apr 07 14:31:07 ndec: tiwlan-wl1271 will also be ready after 11.04 release? Apr 07 14:31:21 ok Apr 07 14:31:56 diwic, I check with maggie_ and the reason that function is different is because she add new code after I send you the patches, it was the initial code for the jack detection, she is just about to answer to the list explaining the points we are concerned about Apr 07 14:36:19 ogra_, also, for being able to test the UCM even at Alsa level (alsaucm) you need the configuration files I send: 'PA_UCM_cofigFiles.tar.gz' (just remember is it really a .bz2 file, I need to change the extention) Apr 07 14:42:00 hrw: there is no tiwlan-wl1271 anymore. the .38 kernel which is already in natty has built in support for wl127x Apr 07 14:45:05 so only fw is lacking? Apr 07 14:45:20 [508763.406768] wl1271_sdio: probe of mmc1:0001:2 failed with error -22 Apr 07 14:49:51 hrw: the Natty firmware package contains the good one for wl1271. Not sure about this error... Apr 07 14:51:09 diwic, ogra_, What happens is that the patches we send to you contains UCM + 1st part of jack-detection. Now this are 2 different features, and jack-detection interacts with UCM that was this was necessary and you see some 'dummy' functions like 'jack_insert_new_hook_callback', but UCM do not depends on the jack-detection feature, so even though maggie_ will add more code, it will be related to the 2nd part of the jack detection Apr 07 14:51:54 ok Apr 07 14:52:11 GrueMaster: installed natty-beta1 on panda, added pvr-omap4, but i still cannot reproduce your video issue Apr 07 14:52:13 rebooting Apr 07 14:52:18 diwic, ogra_, but the UCM implementation is complete Apr 07 14:52:20 GrueMaster: do you have a panda A1 board? Apr 07 14:56:16 [ 4111.341583] wl1271: ERROR sdio read failed (-110) Apr 07 14:56:16 [ 4111.346893] wl1271: ERROR chip id doesn't match after firmware boot Apr 07 14:56:20 ea1 board Apr 07 14:59:52 ppisati: I'll get back to you after the meeting. Apr 07 14:59:57 after reboot it works Apr 07 15:02:40 BT is seen, but down. "hciconfig hci0 up' fails Apr 07 15:05:12 WIP. Link is https://wiki.canonical.com/UbuntuPlatform/ARM/NattyReleaseNotes Apr 07 15:06:08 hrw: for BT, you have to start 'uim' (http://gitorious.org/uim) during startup (quite fast after BT driver init). As a hack we did it in /etc/rc.local. We miss a clean udev rule or something for doing that. Apr 07 15:07:45 sebjan: what does uim has to bt? Apr 07 15:07:59 Description: Simple and flexible input method collection and library Apr 07 15:14:10 alejandro-gm, are you saying the jack detection feature does not work, and if so, why should we merge it? Would it instead be possible to rip out the jack detection entirely and merge UCM only Apr 07 15:16:39 diwic, yes, the jack detection is not working it is only the 'empty shell' Apr 07 15:17:06 hrw: here are some references to uim: http://www.omappedia.org/wiki/Porting_Guide_BT_FM_GPS Apr 07 15:18:27 diwic, I'm not sure if we can just rip it out I guess there is a reason why maggie_ add the 'prototype' of the funtions in the same patch, but let's ask her Apr 07 15:19:18 maggie_, any comments? Apr 07 15:20:03 alejandro-gm, because that would also rip out the invasive changes to module-udev-detect e g Apr 07 15:20:30 alejandro-gm, so if it does not add extra value to the end user we should not merge it Apr 07 15:21:14 well, release team wouldnt approve nonfunctional additions anyway i think Apr 07 15:23:08 sebjan: thx Apr 07 15:23:28 np Apr 07 15:24:38 diwic: I will send some updates today, jack detection will be working, e.g PA will be able to detect jack insertion and removal, and UCM will be used to set the Headset as device Apr 07 15:25:41 diwic: will you be able to take those changes? or do you prefere to remove jack detection code? Apr 07 15:27:07 maggie_, hi there! Apr 07 15:27:16 hi :) Apr 07 15:28:00 maggie_, well, first I was trying to figure out which patches to review, but you missed that conversation. Apr 07 15:28:33 diwic: yes I missed that part Apr 07 15:29:00 maggie_, how possible would it be to add a module parameter to module-udev-detect that turns on the jack detection stuff? Apr 07 15:29:40 maggie_, I'm thinking that way we could have it turned off by default and only turn it on for omap4, thereby minimizing regression risk Apr 07 15:30:09 diwic: I see, I would need to look at that, there are some flags that I can use Apr 07 15:30:57 maggie_, as for the other, I was asked to review today, the jack detection stuff I looked at earlier was more out of interest Apr 07 15:31:15 maggie_, so I haven't looked that much at the UCM part of it yet Apr 07 15:32:29 diwic: ok, yes your comments were mainly related to jack detection Apr 07 15:32:30 maggie_, but basically, these changes are on the large side for being so late in the development cycle, so if we take them, we want to take every precaution we can that it doesn't blow up anything else. Apr 07 15:33:03 maggie_, do you have any advice on how we can minimize risks for other platforms? Apr 07 15:33:51 diwic: sorry bit confuse, risk related to jack detection or UCM integration? Apr 07 15:34:11 sebjan: looks like this TI uim tool is used to set BT ADDR etc but it also looks that it expects old modules Apr 07 15:34:55 ndec: ? Apr 07 15:36:14 maggie_, well, both, if we decide to take them. Apr 07 15:37:09 hrw: are you testing with the kernel coming with current daily images? Apr 07 15:37:11 diwic: for UCM integration e.g to generate the profiles using the UCM data instead of the current guessing mode there is no risk Apr 07 15:37:44 hrw: yes Apr 07 15:37:51 diwic: if your platform doesn't have the UCM configuration file PA will use the current method, e.g UCM will no be used Apr 07 15:40:10 diwic: for jack detection we are basically listening dev/input/event in all cases but I can look into add some code in order to skip loading module-alsa-jack in case the UCM is not present Apr 07 15:42:07 maggie_, I think I'll have to look at the code being touched by the UCM integration a little bit more closely and see what parts of common code that is changed. I will do this later this evening as I have to go and make dinner now. Apr 07 15:42:45 sebjan: 2.6.38-1207 Apr 07 15:43:06 ndec: so is there any docs for getting BT working with 2.6.38? Apr 07 15:43:07 diwic: ok, good. please send me your comments/questions Apr 07 15:43:24 hrw: no. not yet Apr 07 15:43:28 hrw: the current Natty tree misses a patch series for supporting BT Apr 07 15:43:33 thx Apr 07 16:07:15 hi, I upgraded my arm netbook last night, tried unity and it kicked me back to classic desktop instead of unity 2D, is this known? Apr 07 16:07:46 yes, thats not implemented yet Apr 07 16:08:00 select unity-2d from gdm for now Apr 07 16:08:15 its impressing to hear the fallback worked for you :) Apr 07 16:08:28 GrueMaster: new debs for edid testing posted at bug 753071 Apr 07 16:08:30 (our arm images all default to unity-2d) Apr 07 16:10:13 rsalveti: (GrueMaster wanted me to let you knew that he saw you post before his system went down) Apr 07 16:10:35 NCommander: ok, thanks :-) Apr 07 16:18:13 rsalveti: the debs for edid, that's for OMAP3 or 4? Apr 07 16:18:31 ndec: that's for omap 3, for omap 4 I sent the patches to sebjan Apr 07 16:18:56 rsalveti: ok. just curious what did you do? Apr 07 16:19:14 rsalveti: for some reasons i thought we had this in OMAP4 already, no? Apr 07 16:19:34 ndec, not for dvi Apr 07 16:19:40 ndec: http://kernel.ubuntu.com/git?p=rsalveti/ubuntu-natty.git;a=shortlog;h=refs/heads/ti-omap4-drm Apr 07 16:20:00 the edid parsing we had already, but implemented by the hdmi driver Apr 07 16:20:11 the drm driver now is the responsible for the edid parsing and setting Apr 07 16:20:21 rsalveti: oh... you've taken rob's DRM changes? Apr 07 16:20:40 ndec: yes, and improved it to have it properly working also for dvi Apr 07 16:21:00 rsalveti: that's cool... didn't know. Apr 07 16:21:12 rsalveti: are you going to make the DDK changes too for XRandR? Apr 07 16:21:21 ndec: that's the idea Apr 07 16:21:55 that's why I was first working to get the driver in Apr 07 16:22:42 rsalveti: did you see this: http://adventuresinsilicon.blogspot.com/2011/04/ubuntu-1104-to-be-released-in-days.html? Apr 07 16:23:12 ndec: yeah :-) Apr 07 16:23:23 rsalveti: i was wondering why the auto detect monitor was mentioned ;-) Apr 07 16:23:30 i guess I know now... Apr 07 16:23:58 rsalveti: there are two kernels in your directory. Apr 07 16:24:10 GrueMaster: yup, get the latest Apr 07 16:24:18 GrueMaster: 2.6.38-8.41 Apr 07 16:24:22 ok Apr 07 16:24:23 GrueMaster, cant have enough kernels ;) Apr 07 16:45:43 ogra_: netbook omap image is mia. WTF? Apr 07 16:46:09 omap didnt build Apr 07 16:46:19 I didn't get an email. Apr 07 16:46:19 acorn is up since this morning only Apr 07 16:46:23 Ah. Apr 07 16:46:39 i got one at 3:55 Apr 07 16:46:53 8or 1:55 UTC) Apr 07 16:47:22 I have a headless image. Just no netbook. Apr 07 16:48:06 weird, i have mail for both Apr 07 16:48:50 Tue, 5 Apr 2011 23:45:07 +0000 (UTC) for headless Apr 07 16:48:57 Wed, 6 Apr 2011 01:55:07 +0000 (UTC) for netbook Apr 07 16:49:24 Last email I have is for 6 Apr 2011 01:55:07 +0000 (UTC) for the netbook image. Apr 07 16:49:42 I have a headless image for today. Apr 07 16:49:50 yeah, headless gets built before 0:00 UTC Apr 07 16:50:04 * ogra_ checks Apr 07 16:53:22 rsalveti: Does the edid data get exported to userspace in the new kernel? THought I'd ask while I download. Apr 07 16:53:51 it was build, weird Apr 07 16:54:04 ogra_: Which? Apr 07 16:55:43 /wg 2 Apr 07 16:56:04 No filesystem for armel+omap! Apr 07 16:56:04 + exit 1 Apr 07 16:56:04 make: *** [bin-preinstalled_images] Error 1 Apr 07 16:56:08 hmm Apr 07 16:58:49 hmm, seems it wasnt copied or something Apr 07 17:00:05 GrueMaster: probably like before, I'm checking Apr 07 17:02:04 GrueMaster, i have fired off a new manual build, should be ready in 90min, if not, shout Apr 07 17:02:29 * ogra_ goes for dinner Apr 07 17:02:42 ogra_: re fallback> yeah, I was shocked, it dropped me right into classic Apr 07 17:03:02 well, took about a minute, but no further input required Apr 07 17:07:36 GrueMaster: $ sudo modprobe eeprom Apr 07 17:07:44 GrueMaster: $ decode-edid 3 Apr 07 17:07:50 ok Apr 07 17:08:15 Will try it out once I get to that point. Currently bringing the image to current. Apr 07 17:08:21 GrueMaster: decode-edid comes from the i2c-tools package Apr 07 17:08:30 sure Apr 07 17:09:26 * GrueMaster has had the hiccups for 3 days. Very frustrating when added to leg being wrapped like a mummy. Apr 07 17:14:46 * rsalveti lunch Apr 07 17:19:10 sigh. Jasper is broken...again. Apr 07 17:24:05 GrueMaster, whats wrong ? Apr 07 17:24:49 It isn't rebooting after resizing, and other things. I am looking into it now. Apr 07 17:25:09 The bad edid data from my switch makes it more complicated. Apr 07 17:26:00 not rebooting usually means the script exits before Apr 07 17:28:17 On reboot, it starts over, so I think you are right. Apr 07 17:28:29 Not easy to watch, though. Apr 07 17:28:36 ARGH ! Apr 07 17:28:41 * ogra_ sees the typo Apr 07 17:28:54 missing closing single quote, grmpf Apr 07 17:29:55 thats what you get if you work with vim without syntax on grmbl Apr 07 17:31:11 I am very limited in mobility atm, and respectfully request that basic code be checked before it is inserted into the images. Apr 07 17:32:01 I can't afford to waste what limited time I can sit in my office looking at boot issues that shouldn't exist. I need to be able to do image testing. Apr 07 17:36:15 fixed and uploaded Apr 07 17:36:27 sorry, i tested that but with a different branch Apr 07 17:37:33 Well, I have ~20 minutes left before I need to return to the couch. I'll finish testing the kernel for omap, then I'm back to what I can test remotely. Apr 07 17:37:53 sure Apr 07 17:42:40 maggie_, still around? Apr 07 17:44:12 ...seems not Apr 07 17:54:10 diwic, I have her contact on gtalk, do you want me to ping her? Apr 07 17:55:26 alejandro-gm, hm, I'm currently writing up my review and have a few suggestions but I could just as well write that in the review Apr 07 17:57:19 maggie_, hi there Apr 07 17:57:31 diwic: hi, I'm back Apr 07 17:58:23 maggie_, working hard with the PA stuff - how's it coming along? Apr 07 17:59:03 I'm checking the card_name part Apr 07 17:59:37 maggie_, you were talking about adding more jack detection code today, are you still thinking of that or should we skip that part for the time being? Apr 07 18:01:33 maggie_, you were talking about adding more jack detection code today, are you still thinking of that or should we skip that part for the time being? Apr 07 18:01:35 diwic: sorry I'm having connection issues Apr 07 18:02:03 diwic: yes, I'll send some code today, it is early here Apr 07 18:03:36 maggie__, ok. Are you located in west US? Apr 07 18:03:37 diwic: if you can wait, based on the progress I made today you can decide to skip or take the jack detection code Apr 07 18:03:42 yeap Apr 07 18:04:04 dwic: same as Dallas time Apr 07 18:04:20 maggie__, I'll write my review based on current code as I probably will be asleep by then (I'm in Sweden). Apr 07 18:04:41 diwic: (I'm in mexico) Apr 07 18:04:49 right Apr 07 18:05:35 diwic: that is ok, the UCM part has been tested more, you can review that part Apr 07 18:15:04 rsalveti: Tested your kernel and updated bug 753071 with the results. Looks good. Ship it. Apr 07 18:15:18 maggie__, ogra_, here' Apr 07 18:15:35 Hmmm. bugbot is mia. Apr 07 18:15:39 here's the review: bug 746023 Apr 07 18:16:05 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/alsa-lib/+bug/746023/comments/7 Apr 07 18:18:40 diwic: thanks, reading your review Apr 07 18:20:32 maggie__, do ask if you have any question regading the review Apr 07 18:20:39 regarding Apr 07 18:25:26 diwic: I could move some ucm functionallity (like parsing the verbs) to a new .c file, but we still have the main code in module-alsa-card Apr 07 18:33:12 maggie__, hm, ok, I guess the more you could move the better Apr 07 18:33:34 diwic: ok, I'll check Apr 07 18:35:07 maggie__, also since we're more likely to take the UCM code than the jack detection code make sure it's easy to see which patch belongs to which functionality (no patch should include a little of each) Apr 07 18:37:45 diwic: ok, then I will basically split the create_ucm_profiles patche into ucm code and jack detection code Apr 07 18:38:03 yes Apr 07 18:38:51 diwic: I will send the changes to alejandro Apr 07 18:45:10 GrueMaster: cool, thanks Apr 07 18:51:47 maggie__, do you need me for anything? Otherwise I'll log off for today. Apr 07 18:52:13 maggie__, I hope you felt the review made sense; otherwise please tell me Apr 07 18:52:54 diwic: its ok Apr 07 18:53:14 maggie__, I hope you felt the review made sense; otherwise please tell me Apr 07 18:54:31 diwic: thanks I'll let you know Apr 07 20:15:18 Hey all **** ENDING LOGGING AT Fri Apr 08 02:59:58 2011