**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Wed Dec 22 02:59:56 2021
Dec 22 06:43:55 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: Good morning! Did you get audiosystem-passthrough built already?
Dec 22 07:03:15 <HerrieTP_> Morning!
Dec 22 07:04:08 <HerrieTP_> erikinkinenfi[m]: No not yet
Dec 22 07:04:25 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: I got it built.
Dec 22 07:04:25 <HerrieTP_> Was getting stuck with ld error
Dec 22 07:04:36 <HerrieTP_> Ah nice!
Dec 22 07:04:49 <erikinkinenfi[m]> https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/q392gBWQgr/
Dec 22 07:05:06 <HerrieTP_> I was a bit side tracked with PPP but got most of sensors working there now :)
Dec 22 07:07:13 <HerrieTP_> Ah nice! I was missing the last bits at my end
Dec 22 07:07:43 <HerrieTP_> I always get confused with c++ code and how it all works when compiling with linkers etc
Dec 22 07:08:11 <HerrieTP_> I have a draft recipe for hidl but you might have figured that one out already too?
Dec 22 07:14:59 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Yeah, I did figure it out too but it doesn't seem to work at runtime.
Dec 22 07:18:14 <JaMa> morning
Dec 22 07:19:07 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/TgkJczF2Wf/
Dec 22 07:19:35 <erikinkinenfi[m]> JaMa: Good morning to you too!
Dec 22 07:24:26 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Ah, I think the sink is suspended in call for an unknown reason.
Dec 22 07:24:27 <erikinkinenfi[m]> State: SUSPENDED
Dec 22 07:38:21 <Herrie> It could be voicecall needs a bump somehow?
Dec 22 07:39:35 <erikinkinenfi[m]> It was not the suspension, something else is wrong. Values from pactl seem correct, so I'd say the problem is in the pa modules somehow.
Dec 22 07:40:28 <erikinkinenfi[m]> droid-card is set to voicecall mode which is correct.
Dec 22 07:40:53 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I cannot still hear anything from the other party in the call.
Dec 22 07:42:29 <Herrie> Probably something in a .pa that needs adjusting
Dec 22 07:44:40 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Well, I adjusted that as well and the modules get loaded properly.
Dec 22 07:54:17 <Herrie> But still doesn't work?
Dec 22 07:56:32 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: no
Dec 22 08:05:26 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: I think it is missing a dependency.
Dec 22 08:06:09 <erikinkinenfi[m]> audiosystem-passthrough should be able to communicate with pulseaudio via dbus but we do not have module-dbus-protocol at all.
Dec 22 08:23:17 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: fixed!
Dec 22 08:23:18 <erikinkinenfi[m]> https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/ZyB2hymccY/
Dec 22 08:23:53 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Also, this needs top be in .pa file: load-module module-dbus-protocol
Dec 22 08:24:04 <HerrieTP> What was missing?
Dec 22 08:25:00 <erikinkinenfi[m]> A dependency of: module-dbus-protocol
Dec 22 08:25:26 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: it needs top be installed on the system + loaded in pa.
Dec 22 08:52:53 <HerrieTP_> Don't you also need a local config file for the audio passthrough?
Dec 22 08:54:07 <erikinkinenfi[m]> HerrieTP_: No?
Dec 22 08:54:48 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I have never had a config file for that.
Dec 22 08:56:04 <HerrieTP_> OK well I was reading something in description of repo
Dec 22 08:56:14 <HerrieTP_> But maybe it's all automagic
Dec 22 09:12:10 <erikinkinenfi[m]> How does one write app for LuneOS?
Dec 22 09:12:20 <erikinkinenfi[m]> s/app/apps/
Dec 22 09:30:41 <HerrieTP_> In QT/QML or JS with Enyo 1.0/2.0 or Enact framework
Dec 22 09:31:08 <HerrieTP_> What kind of app you'd be interested in?
Dec 22 09:31:22 <HerrieTP_> Services can also be with NodeJS 
Dec 22 09:39:09 <erikinkinenfi[m]> HerrieTP_: First, I would like to make a helloworld app but then I would like to experiment with making a music player as I did not find one.
Dec 22 09:41:43 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Of those technologies, I have experience in Qt/Qml.
Dec 22 09:56:34 <Herrie> There's this in webOS OSE: https://github.com/webosose/com.webos.app.mediagallery
Dec 22 09:56:40 <Herrie> Just not sure it does music
Dec 22 10:00:18 <Herrie> This should give you some guidance to get started: https://webos-ports.org/wiki/Getting_Started_-_QML_Apps
Dec 22 10:08:36 <Herrie> BTW there is a legacy app you could sideload for music. It was included in HP's SDK I think, just they never released it
Dec 22 10:08:40 <Herrie> Let me check
Dec 22 10:16:32 <Herrie> Completely untested, so no idea what it does on LuneOS: https://github.com/Herrie82/core-apps/commit/cc74f8e10bd0c796678afe9c4e6f708cfe478cbd
Dec 22 10:16:40 <Herrie> You can just push it to /usr/palm/applications
Dec 22 10:17:06 <Herrie> Then do a "luna-send -n 1 luna://com.palm.applicationManager/rescan '{}'" and you should have the icon
Dec 22 10:18:04 <Herrie> Let me quickly test it in my VirtualBox
Dec 22 10:30:55 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: So, you're partially using original core-apps and partially your own apps?
Dec 22 10:32:50 <Herrie> erikinkinenfi[m]: Yeah HP only released some apps when they open sourced the OS
Dec 22 10:32:58 <Herrie> However in their SDK there were more
Dec 22 10:33:24 <Herrie> And we still have the legacy "Doctors" (read ROMS) where we can extract things from, but legal status of course is tricky
Dec 22 10:33:42 <Herrie> MusicPlayer app needs some permission fixes it seems
Dec 22 10:34:18 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: So, the plan is to deprecate original apps at some point?
Dec 22 10:35:02 <Herrie> Well it depends... The ones that work well, why not keep them. The ones that don't or missing, replace
Dec 22 10:37:08 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: Btw, why do the original apps scale differently? They are much smaller on my screen and a bit difficult to use.
Dec 22 10:38:21 <Herrie> Well original apps are in JS (Enyo 1.0), our new apps either in Enyo 2.0 or QML
Dec 22 10:38:29 <Herrie> They are rendered differently. Could be adjusted though
Dec 22 10:39:07 <Herrie> Some of the original apps were "hacked" by HP to be running on a tablet with 1024 * 768 resolution. Could be some (minor) CSS tweaks are needed to have them behave on phones again
Dec 22 10:39:41 <Herrie> They were originally running on phones with webOS 2.0/2.1/2.2, then HP rushed webOS 3.0 to the market for the HP Touchpad and did some hackidy hack things like fixing resolutions
Dec 22 10:40:33 <Herrie> There is an app archive at: http://appcatalog.webosarchive.com/showMuseum.php
Dec 22 10:40:56 <Herrie> The majority of the apps probably won't work, but you might find some that do
Dec 22 10:48:22 <Herrie> It could be that some of the values you tweaked yesterday like gridUnit or compatDPI might help there
Dec 22 10:54:44 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: adjusting compatDPI seems to work.
Dec 22 10:59:44 <Herrie> Ok good :)
Dec 22 10:59:57 <Herrie> This musicplayer app makes my qtwebengine crash
Dec 22 11:00:05 <Herrie> And there are some permission errors as well
Dec 22 11:00:16 <Herrie> Not really sure what's up there, because it seems it should be working but well
Dec 22 11:08:46 <Herrie> Tofe: for sensorfwd: You have any idea what these transformation_matrix values represent? https://github.com/webOS-ports/meta-webos-ports/blob/hardknott/meta-luneos/recipes-support/sensorfw/sensorfw/sensord-pinephone.conf#L12
Dec 22 11:09:25 <Herrie> I've been toying a bit with it, but not really working 100% yet. Either screen is rotated 180 degrees, 90 degrees or rotates in the wrong direction for example
Dec 22 11:09:32 <Herrie> Good news is that they do work in general now
Dec 22 11:09:52 <Herrie> Also curious where I could locate those interval values
Dec 22 11:10:13 <Herrie> Seems it uses mpu6500 instead of mpu6050
Dec 22 11:18:55 <Herrie> erikinkinenfi[m]: Can you paste your .pa file? I'll prepare the PR so we can merge the bits for hidl & audiosystem-passthrough
Dec 22 11:19:08 <Herrie> Just want to double check I have it right
Dec 22 11:21:15 <erikinkinenfi[m]> https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/nVJxdH3Zhy/
Dec 22 11:21:46 <erikinkinenfi[m]> The interesting lines are 41 and 45
Dec 22 11:36:22 <Herrie> OK, shouldn't we check to make sure that load-module module-protocol-dbus exists as well?
Dec 22 11:36:27 <Herrie> I can imagine cases where it's not there?
Dec 22 11:47:15 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Oh, yes it should.
Dec 22 11:56:08 <Herrie> File is called module-protocol-dbus.so I guess?
Dec 22 12:23:01 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: module-dbus-protocol.so
Dec 22 12:25:23 <erikinkinenfi[m]> And: load-module module-dbus-protocol
Dec 22 12:25:51 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I think I sent an old version of my .pa file which had those the wrong way around.
Dec 22 12:28:54 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: I managed to write a helloworld app but it doesn't seem to handle scaling correctly. The text of 20pt is way too small.
Dec 22 12:30:28 <HerrieTP_> In JS or QML?
Dec 22 12:30:39 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Qml
Dec 22 12:31:42 <erikinkinenfi[m]> https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/Fd5j9qg4F7/
Dec 22 12:53:48 <Herrie> Good question, should work I would say.. You might want to add: https://github.com/webOS-ports/org.webosports.app.firstuse/blob/master/qml/TimeZonePage.qml#L23
Dec 22 12:53:54 <Herrie> This is on device or QtCreator?
Dec 22 13:16:01 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: on device
Dec 22 13:17:38 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Adding the line you suggested did not change anything.
Dec 22 13:21:35 <Herrie> OK and how are you launching it?
Dec 22 13:22:12 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: tapping an icon it the shell.
Dec 22 13:22:54 <Herrie> OK, did you add a proper appinfo.json? https://github.com/webOS-ports/org.webosports.app.firstuse/blob/master/appinfo.json
Dec 22 13:23:07 <Herrie> You might want to have 	"useLuneOSStyle": "true", in there as well
Dec 22 13:26:02 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I have this: https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/MCDD7VC4Ny/
Dec 22 13:28:14 <Herrie> That should be OK I'd say
Dec 22 13:28:19 <Herrie> Not really sure what's up then
Dec 22 13:34:57 <Herrie> Let me try here
Dec 22 13:40:34 <Herrie> Hmmz here nothing on screen even it seems
Dec 22 13:42:43 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: I have also a main.qml: https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/nXQ5gfvtFf/
Dec 22 13:54:32 <Herrie> OK now I get something on screen, also small indeed
Dec 22 13:55:54 <Herrie> Really not sure what's up here
Dec 22 13:56:39 <erikinkinenfi[m]> The phone app uses the same font size in the text "No calls yet" but it seems much larger.
Dec 22 14:03:54 <HerrieTP_> Yes same for FirstUse
Dec 22 14:07:27 <Herrie> No clues in journalctl?
Dec 22 14:11:32 <erikinkinenfi[m]> No but it seems to affect only text and label objects. a switch renders with correct size but the text attached to it renders too small.
Dec 22 14:12:22 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie:https://pastebin.ubuntu.com/p/ZHcVhgBhFy/
Dec 22 14:24:46 <Herrie> I guess when you put it inside a Column it might work. As you can see here: https://github.com/webOS-ports/org.webosports.app.firstuse/blob/master/qml/FinishedPage.qml there's BasePage->Column->Label/Text/TextField
Dec 22 14:29:39 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: no, column did not help.
Dec 22 14:50:14 <Herrie> And a BasePage?
Dec 22 14:51:21 <eriki73[m]> I tried that but didn
Dec 22 14:51:23 <eriki73[m]> 't help
Dec 22 15:00:24 <Herrie> Hmmz weird
Dec 22 15:01:00 <Herrie> Sometimes it helps to do things in QtCreator, though getting those LuneOS Component & LuneOS Style bits setup is a bit of a pain (at least on Windows), not sure how it's on Linux
Dec 22 15:14:58 <Herrie> If something is wrong syntax wise, journalctl should tell you too, but QtCreator has a "nice IDE" where you can see it while testing. It's pretty good for quick iterations & development
Dec 22 15:25:58 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: Nah, I just rewrote the app with enact.
Dec 22 15:27:03 <Herrie> Hehe also an option
Dec 22 15:27:19 <Herrie> Just there's not really a "mobile friendly" theme for Enact from what I know
Dec 22 15:27:25 <Herrie> But maybe it's there by now
Dec 22 15:27:34 <Herrie> All Enact stuff is for LG's TV's mainly
Dec 22 15:27:46 <Herrie> So UI size is all a bit different scale factor ;)
Dec 22 15:34:51 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: yep, I noticed that.
Dec 22 15:35:15 <erikinkinenfi[m]> It works quite well, actually.
Dec 22 15:44:42 <Herrie> Well in general it's some kind of React, so there should be "mobile friendly" UI/Themes
Dec 22 16:00:08 <Tofe> Morning
Dec 22 16:00:39 <Tofe> Sorry I'm not there that much these days, quite busy with the family stuff 
Dec 22 16:02:15 <Tofe> Herrie: for sensorfw rotation matrix, it's just a 3x3 rotation matrix, with the coordinates for the X,Y,Z vectors of the accelerator
Dec 22 16:03:24 <Tofe> for pinephone we have x,y,z = Y,-X,Z
Dec 22 16:04:33 <Tofe> of course, we usually have z=cross(x,y) so only 2 vectors are really tweakable 
Dec 22 16:49:13 <Herrie> erikinkinenfi[m]: You seem to know a thing or 2 about PulseAudio as well
Dec 22 16:49:25 <Herrie> Any thought on how I can debug the playback on PinePonePro not working?
Dec 22 16:49:41 <Herrie> Seems I finally got the alsa-ucm config OK and that works, however no sound yet
Dec 22 16:50:47 <erikinkinenfi[m]> My knowledge on PA is limited to Halium devices. In your case, I would test playing with aplay directly through alsa and see if it works.
Dec 22 16:56:38 <Herrie> aplay also doesn't output any sound
Dec 22 16:56:45 <Herrie> Maybe I need to fix the samplerate
Dec 22 17:05:30 <Herrie> It all looks OK, but I don't hear anything
Dec 22 17:05:32 <Herrie> Really weird
Dec 22 17:18:23 <Herrie> Must be something silly really
Dec 22 17:24:53 <Herrie> Ok will move back to Mobian where it works and do some more debugging there with alsa etc
Dec 22 18:10:18 <Tofe> Herrie: does "pactl list" output something that matches your UCM config?
Dec 22 18:11:00 <HerrieTP_> Tofe: Yeah that all seems good
Dec 22 18:11:36 <HerrieTP_> Just UCM config is being changed between 1.2.5 and 1.2.6 so that's not helping
Dec 22 18:11:48 <HerrieTP_> Also some symbolic links need to be created etc
Dec 22 18:12:15 <HerrieTP_> Main diff I can spot is that Debian is on PA 15 and we're on 14.2 I think
Dec 22 18:15:14 <Tofe> could it be the UCM is in UCM1 format and PA dropped support for it ? 
Dec 22 18:15:33 <Tofe> I doubt it though, the PP UCM was already UCM2
Dec 22 18:16:25 <HerrieTP_> Yeah
Dec 22 18:17:05 <HerrieTP_> We'll they've been breaking stuff in a point release for Alsa and some are using 1.2.5, others 1. 2.6
Dec 22 18:17:23 <HerrieTP_> So I'm now just running side by side doing various commands and checks
Dec 22 18:17:55 <HerrieTP_> Other difference is that I'm on bleeding edge kernel as well
Dec 22 18:18:02 <HerrieTP_> So will narrow it down
Dec 22 18:18:22 <HerrieTP_> I don't get any alsa/ucm errors anymore after fixing config
Dec 22 18:18:44 <HerrieTP_> amixer and alsamixer seem OK, volume 100% not muted
Dec 22 18:19:17 <HerrieTP_> Just no sound output in LuneOS but OK in Mobian via aplay
Dec 22 18:19:31 <HerrieTP_> Config looks identical so a bit puzzled
Dec 22 18:19:51 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I started experimenting with creating an enact theme.
Dec 22 18:20:16 <erikinkinenfi[m]> I managed to change the bg color already.
Dec 22 18:20:16 <HerrieTP_> In general alsa is on a directer level to hardware right? PA is an additional layer right?
Dec 22 18:20:57 <erikinkinenfi[m]> HerrieTP_: PA is a layer over alsa, correct.
Dec 22 18:21:14 <erikinkinenfi[m]> PA uses alsa as backend in other words.
Dec 22 18:24:59 <Herrie> OK so I should focus on alsa
Dec 22 18:26:41 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: if aplay doesn't work, yes indeed.
Dec 22 18:31:23 <Herrie> Well it doesn't give any errors, pretends to be palying, but no sound
Dec 22 18:38:17 <Herrie> erikinkinenfi[m]: Nice on the Enact!
Dec 22 19:18:27 <Herrie> Ooh I got sound
Dec 22 19:18:34 <Herrie> Seems I needed a proper reboot after fixing config
Dec 22 19:21:23 <erikinkinenfi[m]> Herrie: Although it is pretty WIP, I uploaded my theme to: https://github.com/erikinkinen/enact-theme-lune
Dec 22 19:22:40 <erikinkinenfi[m]> And good that you got sound working on ppp. Now, I have to buy one when explorer edition comes out. :P
Dec 22 19:33:11 <Herrie> Still fighting a bit with sensors and didn't touch the phone stack yet (though I get signal bars, so that's a good sign, modem looks good in logs, so don't expect too many issues)
Dec 22 20:09:30 <Herrie> OK sensors more or less behave it seems now. ALS works properly by the looks of it. Rotation is 80% there too
Dec 22 20:11:13 <Tofe> Herrie: I can test on PP if needed, to look for regressions or so
Dec 22 20:11:57 <Tofe> Rotation is 80% there ? it rotates like until 80% ? :p
Dec 22 20:24:44 <Herrie> Tofe: Well it seems to work pretty OK, just when rotated 180 degrees it shows the screen normal instead of upside down
Dec 22 20:24:52 <Herrie> It rotates in the correct direction
Dec 22 20:25:10 <Herrie> Just both clockwise and counterclockwise 180 degrees it shows "normal" instead of upside down
Dec 22 20:26:14 <Herrie> This is with -1,0,0,0,-1,0,0,0,1
Dec 22 20:28:12 <Herrie> But audio seems to be working, power button works, other sensors (except for magnetometer it seems) also
Dec 22 21:19:58 <Herrie> Tofe: I seem to have issues with the charging status... As you know my understanding of C++ isn't that great, but I think we *MIGHT* need to extend charger.c, specifically: https://github.com/webosose/nyx-modules/blob/master/src/charger/charger.c#L273
Dec 22 21:20:32 <Herrie> Battery status seems decent, however it doesn't give me a charging indicator... 
Dec 22 21:22:25 <Herrie> Ah nevermind, seems I might be wrong ;)
Dec 22 21:22:29 <Herrie> Let me try somethng first
Dec 22 23:02:04 <Herrie> Nope still not detecting the charger properly
Dec 22 23:03:11 <Herrie> udevadm gives me the following: https://bpa.st/3QOA
**** ENDING LOGGING AT Thu Dec 23 02:59:56 2021